Third-party punishment is common across human societies but varies with socioecology

Authors:

Abstract
Punishment systems are central to maintaining human cooperation, yet how they vary across societies remains poorly understood. Different theoretical frameworks make distinct predictions about who third-party punishment (3PP) defends and the socioecological conditions under which it occurs. We test such predictions using a new cross-cultural dataset of 3961 ethnographic texts (coded 11893 times) from 60 largely nonindustrial societies. We code evidence for second- and third-party punishment and, when third-party punishment is documented, whether it is enacted on behalf of kin, social partners, or the broader community. Using Bayesian multilevel regression models, we test preregistered hypotheses linking these different forms of punishment to society-level measures of complexity (i.e., technological and social differentiation, resource-use intensification, community size) and kinship intensity. We find that third-party punishment is widespread across societies and ethnographic texts, occurring more frequently than second-party punishment. Aggregated across relational subtypes, third-party punishment shows weak associations with socioecology; disaggregated, it shows distinct and theoretically meaningful patterns. Generalized 3PP on behalf of community members is positively associated with technological and social differentiation, while kin-directed 3PP is positively associated with kinship intensity and negatively associated with technological and social differentiation. Contrary to our prediction, partner-directed 3PP shows a robust negative association with resource-use intensification. Second-party punishment is negatively associated with technological and social differentiation. These findings show that socioecological structures shape not only the presence of punishment but also the forms it takes and whom it is used to defend, revealing distinct punishment regimes rather than a single enforcement continuum.