Robotic versus Open Partial Nephrectomy: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
Authors:
Open Access
- 16 April 2014
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 9 (4) , e94878
Abstract
To critically review the currently available evidence of studies comparing robotic partial nephrectomy (RPN) and open partial nephrectomy (OPN). A comprehensive review of the literature from Pubmed, Web of Science and Scopus was performed in October 2013. All relevant studies comparing RPN with OPN were included for further screening. A cumulative meta-analysis of all comparative studies was performed and publication bias was assessed by a funnel plot. Eight studies were included for the analysis, including a total of 3418 patients (757 patients in the robotic group and 2661 patients in the open group). Although RPN procedures had a longer operative time (weighted mean difference [WMD]: 40.89; 95% confidence interval [CI], 14.39–67.40; p = 0.002), patients in this group benefited from a lower perioperative complication rate (19.3% for RPN and 29.5% for OPN; odds ratio [OR]: 0.53; 95%CI, 0.42–0.67; p<0.00001), shorter hospital stay (WMD: −2.78; 95%CI, −3.36 to −1.92; p<0.00001), less estimated blood loss(WMD: −106.83; 95%CI, −176.4 to −37.27; p = 0.003). Transfusions, conversion to radical nephrectomy, ischemia time and estimated GFR change, margin status, and overall cost were comparable between the two techniques. The main limitation of the present meta-analysis is the non-randomization of all included studies. RPN appears to be an efficient alternative to OPN with the advantages of a lower rate of perioperative complications, shorter length of hospital stay and less blood loss. Nevertheless, high quality prospective randomized studies with longer follow-up period are needed to confirm these findings.Keywords
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Single Institutional Cost Analysis of 325 Robotic, Laparoscopic, and Open Partial NephrectomiesUrology, 2013
- Use, Costs and Comparative Effectiveness of Robotic Assisted, Laparoscopic and Open Urological SurgeryJournal of Urology, 2012
- A Comparison of Robotic, Laparoscopic and Open Partial NephrectomyJSLS : Journal of the Society of Laparoscopic & Robotic Surgeons, 2012
- Multi-Institutional Analysis of Robotic Partial Nephrectomy for Hilar Versus Nonhilar Lesions in 446 Consecutive CasesEuropean Urology, 2011
- Robot-Assisted Partial Nephrectomy: Evaluation of Learning Curve for an Experienced Renal SurgeonJournal of Endourology, 2010
- Robotic-assisted laparoscopic partial nephrectomy: Technique and initial clinical experience with da Vinci robotic systemUrology, 2004
- Classification of Surgical ComplicationsAnnals of Surgery, 2004
- Measuring inconsistency in meta-analysesBMJ, 2003
- Assessing the quality of reports of randomized clinical trials: Is blinding necessary?Controlled Clinical Trials, 1996
- Meta-analysis in clinical trialsControlled Clinical Trials, 1986