Abstract
Soil biogeochemistry differs between tropical and temperate zones and influences the dynamics of soil carbon, nutrients and water. Earth system models used to project future climate change are largely based on a temperate climate framework that does not adequately capture tropical soil processes. In comparison with many temperate soils where 2:1 phyllosilicate clays and nitrogen limitations are often major controls, highly weathered tropical soils (Oxisols and Ultisols) tend to be dominated by kaolinite and Fe/Al oxides. Short-range-order Fe and Al phases play a major role in the organic carbon stabilization, although crystalline iron oxides can also be the dominant stabilization mechanism, because of ligand exchange and nanopore protection. Additionally, these soils have high phosphorus (P) sorption capacity and are highly micro-heterogeneous, even in upland locations. Based on this narrative review, a new conceptual and mechanism-based Tropical Soil Multifunctionality Index (TSMI) is proposed. It integrates soil properties associated with carbon (C) persistence, delivery of P, buffering of hydrological processes and regulation of greenhouse gas fluxes, including N2O flux to the subsoil, and an explicit domain that clearly includes the long-term effects of anthropogenic legacies. The TSMI connects microscale processes such as nanopore protection, oxide-associated biofilms, fungal networks, and rhizosphere P mining with macroscale soil ecosystem functions, thereby supporting improved representation of tropical soils in models. The proposed index remains conceptual and requires regional validation and calibration. To improve the accuracy of climate and food system models and related policies, it is crucial to address scientific mismatches and epistemic inequalities.