Relative roles of microsurgery and stereotactic radiosurgery for the treatment of patients with cranial meningiomas: a single-surgeon 4-year integrated experience with both modalities
Authors:
- Mark E. LinskeyMLMark E. Linskey
- Stephen A. DavisSDStephen A. Davis
- Vaneerat RatanatharathornVRVaneerat Ratanatharathorn
- 1 January 2005
- journal article
- Published by Journal of Neurosurgery Publishing Group (JNSPG) in Journal of Neurosurgery
- Vol. 102, 59-70
Abstract
Object.The authors sought to assess the respective roles of microsurgery and gamma knife surgery (GKS) in the treatment of patients with meningiomas.Methods.The authors culled from a 4-year prospective database data on 74 cases of meningiomas. Thirty-eight were treated with GKS and 35 with microsurgery. Simpson Grade 1 or 2 resection was achieved in 86.1% of patients who underwent microsurgery. Patients who underwent GKS received a mean margin dose of 16.4 Gy (range 14–20 Gy). The mean tumor coverage was 94.7%, and the mean conformity index was 1.76. Significant differences between the two treatment groups (GKS compared with microsurgery) included age (mean 60 compared with 50.7 years), volume (mean 7.85 cm3compared with 44.4 cm3), treatment history (55.3% compared with 14.3%), and tumor location (cavernous sinus/petroclival, 14 compared with three). The median follow up was 21.5 months (range 1.5–50 months). In patients with benign meningiomas GKS tumor control was 96.8% with one recurrence at the margin. The recurrence rate was zero of 27 for Simpson Grade 1 or 2 resection and three of four for higher grades in those patients who underwent microsurgery. There was no procedure-related mortality or permanent major neurological morbidity. The mean Karnofsky Performance Scale score was maintained for both forms of treatment. Symptoms improved in 48.4% of patients undergoing microsurgery and 16.7% of those who underwent GKS. Transient and permanent cranial nerve morbidity was 7.9 compared with 2.9%, and 5.3 compared with 8.5% for GKS and microsurgery, respectively. In a patient satisfaction survey 93.1% of microsurgery patients and 91.2% of GKS patients were highly satisfied.Conclusions.Both GKS and microsurgery serve important roles in the overall management of patients with meningiomas. Both are safe and effective and provide high degrees of satisfaction when used for differentially selected patients.Keywords
This publication has 54 references indexed in Scilit:
- Primary meningiomas of the jugular fossaJournal of Neurosurgery, 2002
- Effectiveness of preoperative administration of an N-methyl-d-aspartate antagonist to enhance cochlear neuron resistance to intraoperative traumatic stress: an experimental studyJournal of Neurosurgery, 2000
- Gamma knife surgery for skull base meningiomasSurgical Neurology, 1999
- Dose—response tolerance of the visual pathways and cranial nerves of the cavernous sinus to stereotactic radiosurgeryJournal of Neurosurgery, 1998
- Long-term Follow-up of Patients with Meningiomas Involving the Cavernous Sinus: Recurrence, Progression, and Quality of LifeNeurosurgery, 1996
- Radiation-Induced Edema after Gamma Knife Treatment for MeningiomasStereotactic and Functional Neurosurgery, 1996
- Seemingly complete removal of histologically benign intracranial meningioma: Late recurrence rate and factors predicting recurrence in 657 patients. A multivariate analysisSurgical Neurology, 1986
- Atypical and anaplastic meningiomas: Radiology, surgery, radiotherapy, and outcomeSurgical Neurology, 1986
- The growth rate of intracranial meningiomas and its relation to histology. An analysis of 43 patientsSurgical Neurology, 1985
- Stereotactic radiosurgery.Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery & Psychiatry, 1983