Trends in hoaxes of academic communication
Author:
Preprint
Abstract
Academic journals use peer review to weed out false information, but peer review and other editorial processes are normally confidential. Therefore, individuals sometimes create hoaxes to test whether editorial processes are as robust as they are claimed, or whether they are done at all. This article tracks the occurrence of hoaxes aimed at scholarly publishers and academic conferences since 2000. Since 2009, successful hoaxes usually appeared at a year of one or more a year, usually motivated by academics or journalists exposing so-called “predatory” journals. The apparent rise in the number of hoaxes reflects a lack of transparency in editorial processes at both legitimate and “predatory” journals. Reaction of academic communities to hoaxes varies widely depending on the perceived intent of the target of the hoaxes and whether the hoax demonstrates what the hoaxer claims.Keywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- Predatory journals: no definition, no defenceNature, 2019
- Why Articles in Arts and Humanities Are Being Retracted?Publishing Research Quarterly, 2019
- Retractions covered by Retraction Watch in the 2013–2015 period: prevalence for the most productive countriesScientometrics, 2018
- Predatory journals recruit fake editorNature, 2017
- Stings, Hoaxes and Irony Breach the Trust Inherent in Scientific PublishingPublishing Research Quarterly, 2016
- The Ethics of Ironic Science in Its Search for SpoofScience and Engineering Ethics, 2014
- Penetrating the Omerta of Predatory Publishing: The Romanian ConnectionScience and Engineering Ethics, 2014
- Investigating journals: The dark side of publishingNature, 2013
- Predatory publishers are corrupting open accessNature, 2012
- Fashionable Nonsense: Postmodern Intellectuals' Abuse of SciencePhysics Today, 1999