Lag-Time to Publication in Plastic Surgery

Authors:
  • DLDavid T. Lee
    David T. Lee
  • JLJason LaCombe
    Jason LaCombe
  • CCChristina K. Chung
    Christina K. Chung
  • AKAhlia Kattan
    Ahlia Kattan
  • GLGordon K. Lee
    Gordon K. Lee

Abstract
Lag-times between article submission, acceptance, and publication may interfere with the timely distribution of primary literature and may impact the ability of plastic surgeons to practice evidence-based medicine. This study evaluates publication lag-times in plastic surgery and compares them with those in major scientific journals. We reviewed all original articles published in 2008 in Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Annals of Plastic Surgery, Journal of Plastic, Reconstructive and Aesthetic Surgery, Microsurgery, Science, Nature, and Cell. Dates of article submission, acceptance, online publication, and print publication were recorded along with article parameters such as continent of origin, type of surgery, level of evidence, body region, and number of figures and tables. Statistical analysis was performed with significance set at P < 0.05. One thousand four hundred thirty-nine original articles met the inclusion criteria, of which 457 articles (31.8%) were from Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, 207 (14.4%) from Journal of Plastic, Reconstructive and Aesthetic Surgery, 204 (14.2%) from Annals of Plastic Surgery, 108 (7.5%) from Microsurgery, 68 (4.7%) from Science, 142 (9.9%) from Nature, and 253 (17.6%) from Cell. Articles published in plastic surgery journals had a mean submission-to-print lag-time of 463.4 days compared to 201.3 days in other scientific journals (P < 0.001). No statistically significant correlation was found between lag-times in plastic surgery and the number of figures and tables or the level of evidence. Plastic surgery journals have prolonged lag-times. In the current digital age, we suggest timely online publication after manuscript acceptance to decrease unnecessary lag-time. Plastic surgery journals need to further streamline the peer-review process and reduce lag-time to provide information in a timely fashion to its readers. II

This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit: