A Value added’ analysis of the 1996 primary school performance tables
Author:
- 1 June 1998
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Educational Research
- Vol. 40 (2) , 123-137
Abstract
In March 1997 the British Government published the first primary school performance tables giving school‐by‐school results in the 1996 end of key stage 2 (KS2) assessments. The tables were widely criticized for failing to provide a measure of a school's effectiveness since ‘good’ KS2 results might simply reflect a ‘high’ ability pupil intake rather than any characteristics of the teaching or management of the school. This paper uses multi‐level modelling techniques to compare the results from the performance tables in one local education authority with a ‘fair’ analysis as recommended by the School Curriculum and Assessment Authority's National Value Added Project. The results reveal significant differences between schools’ raw results as given in the performance tables and ‘fair’ comparisons of their effectiveness in relation to the ability of their pupils. The analysis also indicates significant variation between schools in their effectiveness in different subject areas (English, mathematics and science), suggesting important information is lost by aggregating results across subjects. Finally, the analysis also provides evidence of under‐achievement among some groups of pupils, with pupils with statements of special educational need, bilingual pupils needing English language support, pupils entitled to free school meals and pupils of Caribbean origin all achieving lower KS2 test results than would be expected from their reasoning ability.Keywords
This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- Pupil Progress during Key Stage 1: a value added analysis of school effectsBritish Educational Research Journal, 1997
- Comparison of value‐added models for secondary‐school effectivenessResearch Papers in Education, 1996
- Using Examination Results as Indicators of School and College PerformanceJournal of the Royal Statistical Society Series A: Statistics in Society, 1996
- Considering primary school effectiveness: an analysis of 1992 Key Stage 1 resultsThe Curriculum Journal, 1995
- How do season of birth and length of schooling affect children's attainment at key stage 1?Educational Research, 1994
- Differential School Effectiveness: results from a reanalysis of the Inner London Education Authority's Junior School Project DataBritish Educational Research Journal, 1993
- School effectiveness studies using administrative dataEducational Research, 1993
- Attainment at Primary Schools: an analysis of variations between schoolsBritish Educational Research Journal, 1991
- The Balance Thesis: contextual effects of ability on pupils’ O‐grade examination resultsOxford Review of Education, 1985