Voters' Reactions to Televised Presidential Debates: Measurement of the Source and Magnitude of Opinion Change

Authors:
  • DLDavid J. Lanoue
    David J. Lanoue
  • PSPeter R. Schrott
    Peter R. Schrott

Abstract
This paper represents a pilot study, investigating the first 1984 presidential debate between Ronald Reagan and Walter Mondale. We conducted surveys of debate watchers and nonwatchers before and after the October encounter, in order to assess the effects of the debate on voters' opinions. A content analysis was employed, allowing us to determine how well the candidates did in discussing the issues of greatest concern to our respondents. We find that Mondale's success in the debate was due largely to his skill as a debater (as opposed to his issue positions), while Reagan was able to effectively exploit the taxation and spending issues. We discuss the implications of this study for understanding the 1984 election, and suggest ways in which the future study of presidential debates might be enhanced.