Abstract
Does an optimal model of criminal policy exist? This Article considers this question by comparatively exploring two criminalization phenomena: overcriminalization in the United States and undercriminalization in Ukraine. Both phenomena are capable of ruining major principles of criminal liability while at the same time destroying public confidence in criminal justice. This Article considers the deficiencies of these criminalization policies, specifically in the area of white-collar crime. It analyzes existing definitions of overcriminalization and undercriminalization as they are known in the United States and in Ukraine. This Article then examines the concepts of overcriminalization and undercriminalization from different perspectives (legislation, prosecution, judicial interpretation, academic research, and public calls for action) and critically compares several white-collar-crime cases in two countries from the criminalization standpoint. The final part of the Article theorizes on how best to identify the proper criminalization balance and on how to achieve that balance.

This publication has 1 reference indexed in Scilit: