Comparison of the Q-fever complement fixation test and two commercial enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays for the detection of serum antibodies againstCoxiella burnetii(Q-fever) in ruminants: Recommendations for use of serological tests on imported animals in New Zealand
Authors:
- 1 October 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in New Zealand Veterinary Journal
- Vol. 57 (5) , 262-268
Abstract
AIM: To make valid recommendations on the use of serological test methods for the detection of serum antibodies in ruminants against Coxiella burnetii (Q-fever), by comparing the performance of the complement fixation test (CFT) and two ELISA, and by identifying reasons for discrepancies between the test methods. METHODS: A total of 73 serum samples from infected cattle, 69 from infected goats, and 100 samples from non-infected cattle and 57 samples from non-infected sheep, as well as 95 samples from infected cattle herds (mix of seropositive and seronegative samples), were tested using the CFT, the IDEXX ELISA (I-ELISA) and the Pourquier ELISA (P-ELISA). A mixed panel of 12 serum samples from sheep from inter-laboratory proficiency testing (proficiency panel) was also tested using the CFT and both ELISA, and further investigated using IgG- and IgM-specific ELISA. RESULTS: Generally, the two commercial ELISA were more sensitive than the CFT for the detection of infected ruminants. Good agreement between ELISA for positive and negative results was found for samples from the infected herd, while results for the positive panels varied between the two ELISA. For the total of the positive serum panels, the I-ELISA detected 95% of samples as positive or suspicious, while the P-ELISA detected only 81%. In the P-ELISA, more samples were considered suspicious (18%) than in the I-ELISA (14%). All sera from noninfected sheep and cattle tested negative in the serological test methods employed, except for one positive sample from a sheep in the P-ELISA. Further investigation revealed that a CFT-positive but ELISA-negative result was due to high IgM and low IgG reactivity. CONCLUSIONS: The two commercial ELISA were more sensitive than the CFT in all panels from infected ruminants. However, they could only detect IgG. The I-ELISA should be the serological test method of choice for cattle, sheep and goats for import testing of animals into New Zealand because it was more sensitive than the P-ELISA and was equally specific to the PELISA and the CFT. For other animal species, such as deer and camelids, the CFT should still be used since none of the ELISA has been evaluated for these species. This study has shown that the two commercial ELISA will detect the majority of infected ruminants but may miss animals that have not developed an IgG response.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Coxiella burnetii Shedding Routes and Antibody Response after Outbreaks of Q Fever-Induced Abortion in Dairy Goat HerdsApplied and Environmental Microbiology, 2009
- Prevention of Coxiella burnetii shedding in infected dairy herds using a phase I C. burnetii inactivated vaccineVaccine, 2008
- Comparison of Coxiella burnetii Shedding in Milk of Dairy Bovine, Caprine, and Ovine HerdsJournal of Dairy Science, 2007
- Comparative diagnostic potential of three serological tests for abortive Q fever in goat herdsVeterinary Microbiology, 2007
- Coxiella burnetiishedding by dairy cowsVeterinary Research, 2007
- Assessing the Within‐herd Prevalence of Coxiella burnetii Milk‐shedder Cows using a Real‐time PCR Applied to Bulk Tank MilkZoonoses and Public Health, 2007
- Effect of vaccination with phase I and phase II Coxiella burnetii vaccines in pregnant goatsVaccine, 2005
- Is Q Fever an emerging or re-emerging zoonosis?Veterinary Research, 2005
- Evaluation of a Novel Commercial Enzyme-Linked Immunosorbent Assay Detecting Coxiella burnetii -Specific Immunoglobulin G for Q Fever Prevaccination Screening and DiagnosisJournal of Clinical Microbiology, 2002
- Q Fever is Absent from New ZealandInternational Journal of Epidemiology, 1993