A meta-analysis and review of holistic face processing.
- 1 January 2014
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Psychological Bulletin
- Vol. 140 (5) , 1281-1302
Abstract
The concept of holistic processing is a cornerstone of face recognition research, yet central questions related to holistic processing remain unanswered, and debates have thus far failed to reach a resolution despite accumulating empirical evidence. We argue that a considerable source of confusion in this literature stems from a methodological problem. Specifically, 2 measures of holistic processing based on the composite paradigm (complete design and partial design) are used in the literature, but they often lead to qualitatively different results. First, we present a comprehensive review of the work that directly compares the 2 designs, and which clearly favors the complete design over the partial design. Second, we report a meta-analysis of holistic face processing according to both designs and use this as further evidence for one design over the other. The meta-analysis effect size of holistic processing in the complete design is nearly 3 times that of the partial design. Effect sizes were not correlated between measures, consistent with the suggestion that they do not measure the same thing. Our meta-analysis also examines the correlation between conditions in the complete design of the composite task, and suggests that in an individual differences context, little is gained by including a misaligned baseline. Finally, we offer a comprehensive review of the state of knowledge about holistic processing based on evidence gathered from the measure we favor based on the 1st sections of our review-the complete design-and outline outstanding research questions in that new context.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Eye Institute (2 R01 EY013441-06A2)
- National Science Foundation (SBE-0542013)
This publication has 100 references indexed in Scilit:
- Neural representations of faces and limbs neighbor in human high-level visual cortex: evidence for a new organization principlePsychological Research, 2011
- Beliefs alter holistic face processing ... if response bias is not taken into accountJournal of Vision, 2011
- Impaired holistic processing in congenital prosopagnosiaNeuropsychologia, 2011
- Perceptual Expertise as a Shift From Strategic Interference to Automatic Holistic ProcessingCurrent Directions in Psychological Science, 2011
- Impaired holistic coding of facial expression and facial identity in congenital prosopagnosiaNeuropsychologia, 2011
- Holistic Processing Predicts Face RecognitionPsychological Science, 2011
- The neural basis of visual object learningTrends in Cognitive Sciences, 2010
- Conditions for Facelike Expertise With ObjectsPsychological Science, 2009
- Face composite effects reveal abnormal face processing in Autism spectrum disordersVision Research, 2009
- Mechanisms of Face PerceptionAnnual Review of Neuroscience, 2008