Legacy effects and recovery potential of carbonate budgets on Seychelles coral reefs

Authors:

Abstract
Coral reef carbonate budgets are fundamental indicators of ecosystem function, underpinning framework accretion and reef growth. Although spatial assessments and short‐term studies exist, multi‐decadal evaluations of net budget states spanning repeated disturbance events remain rare. We analyzed a 31‐year dataset (1994–2025) from reef sites across the inner Seychelles to quantify long‐term coral and gross carbonate production and gross (biological) erosion, and net budget state trends (kg CaCO 3 m −2 yr −1 ) across four thermal stress events (1998, 2010, 2016, 2024). Reefs previously classified as ecologically “recovered” to hard coral‐dominated, or “regime‐shifted” to macroalgal‐dominated states following the 1998 mass bleaching displayed contrasting multi‐decadal net budget trajectories. Coral production rates declined sharply at all sites after 1998, with regime‐shifted reefs exhibiting persistently negative or near‐zero net budgets. In contrast, recovering reefs showed rapid increases in coral production and net budgets until 2014, before being reset by the 2016 bleaching event, which reduced coral production by approximately 50% and drove budgets close to zero. Gross erosion varied comparatively little through time and among site groupings, despite transient post‐bleaching increases in parrotfish erosion and a recent sea urchin mass‐mortality event. Consequently, net budget dynamics were primarily driven by changes in coral production, particularly fluctuations in branching Acropora and Pocillopora . Higher pre‐bleaching dominance of these fast‐growing taxa amplified subsequent declines, implying a legacy effect on magnitudes of change and a trade‐off between high productivity and thermal vulnerability. By 2025, several reefs remain in low or neutral net budget states, raising concerns for framework persistence under future thermal stress.
Funding Information
  • Australian Research Council
  • Leverhulme Trust
  • Royal Society (URF\R\201029)
  • Royal Society (URF\R1\231087)

This publication has 58 references indexed in Scilit: