A systematic literature review of reciprocity in engineering service‐learning/community engagement
Authors:
- David A. DelaineDDDavid A. Delaine
- Sarah RedickSRSarah Redick
- Dhinesh RadhakrishnanDRDhinesh Radhakrishnan
- Amena ShermadouASAmena Shermadou
- Mandy McCormick SmithMSMandy McCormick Smith
- Rohit KandakatlaRKRohit Kandakatla
- Linjue WangLWLinjue Wang
- Claudio FreitasCFClaudio Freitas
- Casey L. DaltonCDCasey L. Dalton
- Jennifer DeBoerJDJennifer DeBoer
Open Access
- 18 October 2023
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Engineering Education
- Vol. 113 (4) , 838-871
Abstract
Background: Scholars agree that reciprocity is a cornerstone of service‐learning and community engagement (SLCE); however, engagement with this concept varies widely in practice and across disciplines. To enhance the potential of SLCE to fulfill its promise for societal impact, engineering education must understand how reciprocity is achieved, recognize barriers that inhibit its progress, and identify strategies for how it can be strengthened.Purpose: We performed this review to understand the ways reciprocity is articulated in the engineering SLCE literature. Drawing from these articulations, we examined the extent of engagement with reciprocity toward providing insights into the design and assessment of SLCE efforts for reciprocity.Scope/Method: We performed a systematic literature review on engineering SLCE at institutes of higher education. Following an established approach to identify and synthesize articles, we developed deductive codes by distilling three well‐articulated orientations of reciprocity. We then analyzed the operationalization of reciprocity in the literature.Results: The literature demonstrated varying degrees of reciprocity. Minimally reciprocal efforts centered university stakeholders. In contrast, highly reciprocal partnerships explicitly addressed the nature of engagement with communities. Findings provide insights into the breadth of practice within reciprocity present in engineering SLCE. Further, analysis suggests that our codes and levels of reciprocity can function as a framework that supports the design and evaluation of reciprocity in SLCE efforts.Conclusions: Our review suggests that to enact more equitable SLCE, researchers and practitioners must intentionally conceptualize reciprocity, translate it into practice, and make visible the ways in which reciprocity is enacted within their SLCE efforts.Keywords
This publication has 54 references indexed in Scilit:
- Systematic Literature Reviews in Engineering Education and Other Developing Interdisciplinary FieldsJournal of Engineering Education, 2014
- Exploring and developing reciprocity in research designInternational Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education, 2013
- Intergenerational Education: The Significance of Reciprocity and PlaceJournal of Intergenerational Relationships, 2012
- Designs on development: engineering, globalization, and social justiceEngineering Studies, 2010
- Engineering and Sustainable Community DevelopmentSynthesis Lectures on Engineers, Technology and Society, 2010
- Bridging the distance: Service learning in international perspectiveNew Directions for Teaching and Learning, 2009
- Indigeneity, an alternative worldview: four R's (relationship, responsibility, reciprocity, redistribution) vs. two P's (power and profit). Sharing the journey towards conscious evolutionSystems Research and Behavioral Science, 2004
- Learning With and Learning From: Reciprocity in Service Learning in Teacher EducationEquity & Excellence in Education, 2003
- From Charity to JusticeAmerican Behavioral Scientist, 2000
- Beyond Causality in The Social Sciences: Reciprocity as a Model of Non-Exploitative Social Relations1983