Deliberative constitutionalism ‘without shortcuts’: On the deliberative potential of Cristina Lafont’s judicial review theory
Open Access
- 13 December 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Global Constitutionalism
- Vol. 12 (2) , 215-233
Abstract
Deliberative constitutionalism is one of the most important developments of recent decades in constitutional theory and practice. It is in this context that Cristina Lafont’s Democracy Without Shortcuts was published. Lafont’s theory provides an opportunity to advance the research agenda on deliberative constitutionalism since she offers a deliberative democratic reinterpretation of judicial review. According to this compelling and powerful idea, citizens can challenge any laws in constitutional courts and thus trigger democratic deliberation about rights. With this issue in mind, this article offers a general approach to deliberative constitutionalism, describes Lafont’s reinterpretation of judicial review, and makes explicit five tensions in this reinterpretation of judicial review vis-à-vis deliberative constitutionalism: (1) the default authority in the interim; (2) the procedural type of constitutional amendment; (3) the scope of judicial review; (4) the irrelevance of constitutional amendments; and (5) the scope of constituent power.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- Deliberative Ideals and Constitutionalism in the Administrative State2018
- The Adventures of the Constituent Power2017
- The lure and the limits of dialogueUniversity of Toronto Law Journal, 2016
- Is Constitutional Rigidity the Problem? Democratic Legitimacy and the Last WordRatio Juris, 2014
- 'We the People' Outside of the Constitution: The Dialogic Model of Constitutionalism and the System of Checks and BalancesCurrent Legal Problems, 2014
- Judicial Review, Constitutional Juries and Civic Constitutional Fora: Rights, Democracy and LawTheoria, 2011
- Constitutional DemocracyPolitical Theory, 2001
- The Irrelevance of Constitutional AmendmentsHarvard Law Review, 2001
- Una defensa de la rigidez constitucionalDoxa. Cuadernos de Filosofía del Derecho, 2000
- A Right-Based Critique of Constitutional RightsOxford Journal of Legal Studies, 1993