Between the creation of the International Union of American Republics in 1890 and the adoption of the Charter of the Organization of American States in 1948, Latin American jurists and diplomats treated regional organisation as a legal-political project. Drawing on archival and other primary sources from across the Americas, this framing article shows how they used law to contest U.S. predominance within a regional system based in Washington, to obtain in law the sovereign equality they could not secure in fact, and to codify Latin American legal positions as international law. In this way, this article recovers an inter-American prehistory of international organisations law that the field has largely overlooked and that sits uneasily with functionalist accounts of organisations as technical instruments of delegated tasks. The article closes by reading three studies of contemporary inter-American practice against this prehistory. Seen in that light, the region’s present institutional practice appears narrower and less inevitable.