The Efficacy of Conversational AI in Rectifying the Theory-of-Mind and Autonomy Biases: Comparative Analysis
Top Cited Papers
Open Access
- 7 February 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Mental Health
- Vol. 12 (1) , e64396
Abstract
Background: The increasing deployment of conversational artificial intelligence (AI) in mental health interventions necessitates an evaluation of their efficacy in rectifying cognitive biases and recognizing affect in human-AI interactions. These biases are particularly relevant in mental health contexts as they can exacerbate conditions such as depression and anxiety by reinforcing maladaptive thought patterns or unrealistic expectations in human-AI interactions. Objective: This study aimed to assess the effectiveness of therapeutic chatbots (Wysa and Youper) versus general-purpose language models (GPT-3.5, GPT-4, and Gemini Pro) in identifying and rectifying cognitive biases and recognizing affect in user interactions. Methods: This study used constructed case scenarios simulating typical user-bot interactions to examine how effectively chatbots address selected cognitive biases. The cognitive biases assessed included theory-of-mind biases (anthropomorphism, overtrust, and attribution) and autonomy biases (illusion of control, fundamental attribution error, and just-world hypothesis). Each chatbot response was evaluated based on accuracy, therapeutic quality, and adherence to cognitive behavioral therapy principles using an ordinal scale to ensure consistency in scoring. To enhance reliability, responses underwent a double review process by 2 cognitive scientists, followed by a secondary review by a clinical psychologist specializing in cognitive behavioral therapy, ensuring a robust assessment across interdisciplinary perspectives. Results: This study revealed that general-purpose chatbots outperformed therapeutic chatbots in rectifying cognitive biases, particularly in overtrust bias, fundamental attribution error, and just-world hypothesis. GPT-4 achieved the highest scores across all biases, whereas the therapeutic bot Wysa scored the lowest. Notably, general-purpose bots showed more consistent accuracy and adaptability in recognizing and addressing bias-related cues across different contexts, suggesting a broader flexibility in handling complex cognitive patterns. In addition, in affect recognition tasks, general-purpose chatbots not only excelled but also demonstrated quicker adaptation to subtle emotional nuances, outperforming therapeutic bots in 67% (4/6) of the tested biases. Conclusions: This study shows that, while therapeutic chatbots hold promise for mental health support and cognitive bias intervention, their current capabilities are limited. Addressing cognitive biases in AI-human interactions requires systems that can both rectify and analyze biases as integral to human cognition, promoting precision and simulating empathy. The findings reveal the need for improved simulated emotional intelligence in chatbot design to provide adaptive, personalized responses that reduce overreliance and encourage independent coping skills. Future research should focus on enhancing affective response mechanisms and addressing ethical concerns such as bias mitigation and data privacy to ensure safe, effective AI-based mental health support.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 57 references indexed in Scilit:
- Revealing the source: How awareness alters perceptions of AI and human-generated mental health responsesInternet Interventions, 2024
- Therapeutic Chatbots as Cognitive-Affective ArtifactsTopoi, 2024
- Talking to a bot or a wall? How chatbots vs. human agents affect anticipated communication qualityComputers in Human Behavior, 2023
- Effect of AI chatbot emotional disclosure on user satisfaction and reuse intention for mental health counseling: a serial mediation modelCurrent Psychology, 2022
- Someone out there? A study on the social presence of anthropomorphized chatbotsComputers in Human Behavior, 2022
- The effect of disease anthropomorphism on compliance with health recommendationsJournal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 2022
- Socio-cognitive biases in folk AI ethics and risk discourseAI and Ethics, 2021
- The mind behind anthropomorphic thinking: attribution of mental states to other speciesAnimal Behaviour, 2015
- Illusion of ControlExperimental Psychology, 2014
- Broadening Our Understanding of Clinical Quality: From Attribution Error to Situated CognitionClinical Pharmacology & Therapeutics, 2012