THE CONSIDERATION OF IMPACTS UPON THE AQUATIC ENVIRONMENT IN ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENTS IN ENGLAND AND WALES
- 1 March 2004
- journal article
- research article
- Published by World Scientific Pub Co Pte Ltd in Journal of Environmental Assessment Policy and Management
- Vol. 06 (01) , 19-49
Abstract
Considerable research has been undertaken on the quality of Environmental Impact Statements as an indicator, albeit superficial, of the effectiveness of Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) practices. Yet there remains a paucity of empirical data on practices at the more detailed level (e.g., for the consideration of certain environmental components and stages of the EIA process), despite the importance of such analyses for the development of grounded measures for enhancing effectiveness. This study contributes to the development of a detailed empirical understanding of EIA practices by examining analyses of impacts upon the aquatic environment (Water Impact Assessment (WIA)) for a sample of 50 development proposals in England and Wales. The research results indicate that WIA practices have improved over time, but a significant proportion of assessments remain unsatisfactory, and the quality of core elements of WIA (e.g., the consideration of alternatives and impact prediction) is particularly problematic. It is suggested that changes made to the EU EIA legislation have not significantly affected WIA practices in England and Wales. However, practices are not as problematic as research indicates is the case for ecological, socio-economic and cumulative impact assessments. Further strengthening the legislative provisions for EIA would partially address a number of specific problems (e.g., inadequate scoping and provision for monitoring). Nevertheless, a comprehensive and concerted strategy for enhancing effectiveness will be required if WIA is fulfil its potential for contributing to the management maxim of sustainable development.Keywords
This publication has 35 references indexed in Scilit:
- Dealing with the cultural heritage aspect of environmental impact assessment in EuropeImpact Assessment and Project Appraisal, 2004
- AN EVALUATION OF THE QUALITY OF ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENTS IN THESSALONIKI, GREECEJournal of Environmental Assessment Policy and Management, 2002
- Cumulative effects assessmentEnvironmental Impact Assessment Review, 2002
- Socio-economic Impacts: Are They Still the Poor Relations in UK Environmental Statements?Journal of Environmental Planning and Management, 2002
- Road Developments in the UK: An Analysis of Ecological Assessment in Environmental Impact Statements Produced between 1993 and 1997Journal of Environmental Planning and Management, 2000
- An evaluation of eia system performance in eight eu countriesEnvironmental Impact Assessment Review, 1999
- The Effect of Environmental Assessment on UK Infrastructure Project Planning DecisionsPlanning Practice & Research, 1997
- Policy And Practice Environmental Assessmentand Planning: A Chronology of Development in England and WalesJournal of Environmental Planning and Management, 1997
- The effects of watercress growing on chalk headwater streams in dorset and hampshireEnvironmental Pollution, 1994
- Assessing the ecological effects of groundwater abstraction on chalk streams: Three examples from Eastern EnglandRegulated Rivers: Research & Management, 1993