Does Social Security Privatization Produce Efficiency Gains?
Authors:
- Shinichi NishiyamaSNShinichi Nishiyama
- Kent SmettersKSKent Smetters
- 1 November 2007
- journal article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in The Quarterly Journal of Economics
- Vol. 122 (4) , 1677-1719
Abstract
While privatizing social security can improve labor supply incentives, it can also reduce risk sharing. We analyze a 50% privatization using an overlapping-generations model where heterogeneous agents with elastic labor supply face idiosyncratic earnings shocks and longevity uncertainty. When wage shocks are insurable, privatization produces about $18,100 of extra resources for each future household after all transitional losses have been compensated for with lump-sum taxes. When wages are not insurable, privatization reduces efficiency by about $2,400 per future household. We check the robustness of these results to different model specifications as well as policy reforms and arrive at several surprising conclusions. First, privatization performs better in a closed economy, where interest rates decline with capital accumulation, than in an open economy. Second, privatization also performs better when an actuarially fair private annuity market does not exist. Third, government matching of private contributions on a progressive basis is not very effective at restoring efficiency and can actually cause harm.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Pareto-Improving Social Security Reform when Financial Markets Are Incomplete!?American Economic Review, 2006
- Consumption Taxes and Economic Efficiency with Idiosyncratic Wage ShocksJournal of Political Economy, 2005
- A Summary of Saving Social Security: A Balanced ApproachSSRN Electronic Journal, 2004
- How effective is redistribution under the social security benefit formula?Journal of Public Economics, 2001
- Simulating Fundamental Tax Reform in the United StatesAmerican Economic Review, 2001
- Social Security Reform with Heterogeneous AgentsReview of Economic Dynamics, 1999
- Projected U.S. Demographics and Social SecurityReview of Economic Dynamics, 1999
- Social security and institutions for intergenerational, intragenerational, and international risk-sharingCarnegie-Rochester Conference Series on Public Policy, 1999
- TWO COMPUTATIONS TO FUND SOCIAL SECURITYMacroeconomic Dynamics, 1997
- A life cycle analysis of social securityEconomic Theory, 1995