Conducting Repeatable Experiments and Fair Comparisons using 802.11n MIMO Networks
Authors:
Open Access
- 20 January 2015
- journal article
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM) in ACM SIGOPS Operating Systems Review
- Vol. 49 (1) , 41-50
Abstract
A commonly used technique for evaluating and comparing the performance of systems using 802.11 (WiFi) networks is to conduct experiments. This approach is appealing and important because it inherently captures critical properties of wireless signal transmission that are difficult to analytically model and simulate. Unfortunately, obtaining consistent and statistically meaningful empirical results using 802.11 networks, even in well-controlled environments, can be quite challenging and time consuming because channel conditions can vary over time. In this paper, we use 2.4 and 5 GHz 802.11n MIMO networks to study different methodologies that could be used to evaluate and compare the performance of different alternatives used in 802.11 systems (e.g., different systems, configurations or algorithms). We first illustrate that some of the more commonly used methods in existing research are flawed and explain why. We then describe a methodology called multiple interleaved trials that, to our knowledge, has not been used for, or studied on, 802.11 networks. We evaluate this methodology and find that it can be used to repeat experiments and to compare the performance of different alternatives. Finally, we discuss other possible applications of this approach for comparative performance evaluations.Keywords
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- Geosphere2014
- Joint rate and channel width adaptation for 802.11 MIMO wireless networks2013
- The N-Of-1 Clinical Trial: The Ultimate Strategy For Individualizing Medicine?Personalized Medicine, 2011
- MIMO rate adaptation in 802.11n wireless networks2010
- Repeatable experiments with mobile nodes in a relocatable WSN testbed2010
- Trends, Advances, and Challenges in Testbed-based Wireless Mesh Network ResearchMobile Networks and Applications, 2010
- RF in the Jungle: Effect of Environment Assumptions on Wireless Experiment Repeatability2009
- Comparison of MANET Routing Protocols Using a Scaled Indoor Wireless GridMobile Networks and Applications, 2008
- Robust rate adaptation for 802.11 wireless networks2006
- MiNT-m2006