Differential impact of test performance characteristics on burden-to-benefit tradeoffs for blood-based colorectal cancer screening: A microsimulation analysis
Authors:
- 2 June 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Medical Screening
- Vol. 30 (4) , 175-183
Abstract
Objectives: To inform the development and evaluation of new blood-based colorectal cancer (CRC) screening tests satisfying minimum United States (US) coverage criteria, we estimated the impact of the different test performance characteristics on long-term testing benefits and burdens. Methods: A novel CRC-Microsimulation of Adenoma Progression and Screening (CRC-MAPS) model was developed, validated, then used to assess different screening tests for CRC. We compared multiple, hypothetical blood-based CRC screening tests satisfying minimum coverage criteria of 74% CRC sensitivity and 90% specificity, to measure how changes in a test's CRC sensitivity, specificity, and adenoma sensitivity (sizes 1–5 mm, 6–9 mm, ≥10 mm) affect total number of colonoscopies (COL), CRC incidence reduction (IR), CRC mortality reduction (MR), and burden-to-benefit ratios (incremental COLs per percentage-point increase in IR or MR). Results: A blood test meeting minimum US coverage criteria for performance characteristics resulted in 1576 lifetime COLs per 1000 individuals, 46.7% IR and 59.2% MR compared to no screening. Tests with increased CRC sensitivity of 99% ( + 25%) vs. increased ≥10 mm adenoma sensitivity of 13.6% ( + 3.6%) both yielded the same MR, 62.7%. Test benefits improved the most with increases in all-size adenoma sensitivity, then size-specific adenoma sensitivities, then specificity and CRC sensitivity, while increases in specificity or ≥10 mm adenoma sensitivity resulted in the most favorable burden-to-benefit tradeoffs (ratios <11.5). Conclusions: Burden-to-benefit ratios for blood-based CRC screening tests differ by performance characteristic, with the most favorable tradeoffs resulting from improvements in specificity and ≥10 mm adenoma sensitivity.Keywords
This publication has 45 references indexed in Scilit:
- Preferences for Blood-Based Colon Cancer Screening Differ by Race/EthnicityAmerican Journal of Health Behavior, 2014
- Multitarget Stool DNA Testing for Colorectal-Cancer ScreeningNew England Journal of Medicine, 2014
- State-Transition Modeling: A Report of the ISPOR-SMDM Modeling Good Research Practices Task Force-3Value in Health, 2012
- Cost-effectiveness of ColonoscopyGastrointestinal Endoscopy Clinics of North America, 2010
- Informed Decision Making Changes Test Preferences for Colorectal Cancer Screening in a Diverse PopulationThe Annals of Family Medicine, 2010
- Polyp Size and Advanced Histology in Patients Undergoing Colonoscopy Screening: Implications for CT ColonographyGastroenterology, 2008
- Cost‐effectiveness of colorectal cancer screening with computed tomography colonographyCancer, 2007
- Clinical Significance of Small Colorectal PolypsDiseases of the Colon & Rectum, 2004
- Reducing Mortality from Colorectal Cancer by Screening for Fecal Occult BloodNew England Journal of Medicine, 1993
- The evolution of cancer of the colon and rectumCancer, 1975