Brazilian Psychiatric Reform: critical arguments of psychiatric hospital professionals
Authors:
- Pedro de Oliveira FilhoPFPedro de Oliveira Filho
- Thelma Maria Grisi VelôsoTVThelma Maria Grisi Velôso
- Lucélia de Almeida AndradeLALucélia de Almeida Andrade
- Ana Clara Noberto CameloACAna Clara Noberto Camelo
- Carolina Guimarães PortoCPCarolina Guimarães Porto
- Virgínia Gonçalves de MeloVMVirgínia Gonçalves de Melo
Open Access
- 1 January 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by FapUNIFESP (SciELO) in Saúde e Sociedade
- Vol. 33 (4) , e230507pt
Abstract
The Brazilian Psychiatry Reform was consolidated after the creation of various services and devices that came to replace the asylum psychiatry system. However, psychiatric hospitals continue to exist, they have not been completely modified and are still part of the mental health services network. This article analyzes arguments developed by professionals from two psychiatric hospitals in João Pessoa, in the state of Paraíba, to criticize the Brazilian Psychiatric Reform, focusing on the rhetorical resources mobilized to present them as objective and factual. This is a qualitative study, in which 42 interviews were obtained and submitted to discourse analysis, according to the proposal of Discursive Social Psychology. The professionals herein interviewed carry out a semantic and pragmatic movement that consists of affirming the ineffectiveness of the Psychiatric Reform while denying any opposition to the values and principles that support it. The statements about the supposed ineffectiveness of the Reform are presented as solid and objective with the use of different resources to produce factuality. Through this process, they present themselves as enlightened, tolerant people guided by the values of the Enlightenment, people who produce a credible account of the Brazilian Psychiatric Reform when they criticize its way of functioning.Keywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- Reforma e contrarreforma psiquiátrica: análise de uma crise sociopolítica e sanitária a nível nacional e regionalCiencia & Saude Coletiva, 2019
- A reforma psiquiátrica no SUS e a luta por uma sociedade sem manicômiosCiencia & Saude Coletiva, 2018
- Identifying and Responding to Possible -isms in Institutional EncountersJournal of Language and Social Psychology, 2015
- Everyday Antiracism in ActionJournal of Language and Social Psychology, 2015
- A reforma e os hospitais psiquiátricos: histórias da desinstitucionalizaçãoPsicologia & Sociedade, 2010
- Além das portarias: desafios da política de saúde mentalPsicologia Em Estudo, 2010
- A reforma psiquiátrica no Brasil: uma (re) visãoCiencia & Saude Coletiva, 2009
- Exclusão social do doente mental: discursos e representações no contexto da reforma psiquiátricaPsico-USF, 2008
- O movimento antimanicomial no BrasilCiencia & Saude Coletiva, 2007
- Quantification Rhetoric—cancer on TelevisionDiscourse & Society, 1991