Methodological Artifact or Persistent Bias?
Authors:
- 1 April 2004
- journal article
- other
- Published by SAGE Publications in Communication Research
- Vol. 31 (2) , 206-233
Abstract
Differences in perceived influences of positive and negative media messages were examined in three experiments with methodological variations. In the first experiment, when the contrast between self and others was clearly highlighted within the framework of a within-subject design, both the third-person effect and the reverse third-person effect were significant. In Experiment 2, when the perceived effect on self and others was evaluated using a between-subjects design, the third-person effect continued to persist, whereas the reverse third-person effect was not evident. The results from Experiment 2 were replicated in Experiment 3 under three levels of accountability. The third-person bias continued to persist even after participants were briefed about the self-serving motivation to appear better than others. These results suggest that the third-person phenomenon is not merely a methodological artifact but a persistent social judgment bias that cannot be easily neutralized, whereas the reverse third-person effect appears to be less robust.Keywords
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- Person-Effects and Heuristic-Systematic ProcessingCommunication Research, 2002
- Behind the Third-Person Effect: Differentiating Perceptual Processes for Self and OtherJournal of Communication, 2001
- Questioning the Value of Realism: Young Adults' Processing of Messages in Alcohol-Related Public Service Announcements and AdvertisingJournal of Communication, 2001
- Social Identity and Perceptions of Media Persuasion: Are We Always Less Influenced Than Others?1Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 1999
- The Role of Self in Third-Person Effects About Body ImageJournal of Communication, 1998
- Evidence for egocentric comparison in social judgment.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1996
- Perceived Persuasive Effects of Product Commercials and Public Service AnnouncementsCommunication Research, 1992
- What We Think Others ThinkCommunication Research, 1991
- Response strategies for coping with the cognitive demands of attitude measures in surveysApplied Cognitive Psychology, 1991
- Ego-Involvement and the Third Person Effect of Televised News CoverageCommunication Research, 1989