Thinking for speaking and thinking for listening: The interaction of thought and language in typical and non-fluent comprehension and production
Authors:
- 1 June 2005
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Language and Cognitive Processes
- Vol. 20 (3) , 417-441
Abstract
In this paper, we reconsider some of the processes that distinguish production and comprehension. In particular, we discuss the specific forms of thinking involved in each: “thinking for speaking” and “thinking for listening” (Black & Chiat, 2000 Black, M. and Chiat, S. 2000. “Putting thoughts into verbs: Developmental and acquired impairments”. In Semantic processing: Theory and practice, Edited by: Best, W. , Bryan, K. and Maxim, J. 52–79. London: Whurr Publishers. [Google Scholar] ; Slobin, 1996 Slobin, D. I. 1996. “From ‘thought and language’ to thinking for speaking”. In Rethinking linguistic relativity, Edited by: Gumperz, J. J. and Levinson, S. C. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. [Google Scholar] ). We argue that thinking for speaking (or for any form of language output) crucially involves schematisation or “paring down” of conceptual information (Dipper, 1999 Dipper , L. T. ( 1999 ). Event processing in non-fluent aphasia: The interaction between verbs, sentences and events; with data from 6 people with non-fluent aphasia . Unpublished Ph.D. Thesis, UCL . [Google Scholar] ), a process partly driven by the language system itself. Thinking for listening, on the other hand, involves an “enrichment” of skeletal conceptual information derived from the linguistic input, using pragmatic principles. Production and comprehension involve distinct forms of interaction between thought and language, and should not be characterised as a simple reversal of the same processes. This approach allows us to account for different patterns of production and comprehension in non-fluent aphasia, and predict some of the factors the facilitate processing for people with these language impairments.Keywords
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- Patterns of Comprehension and Production of Nouns and Verbs in Agrammatism: Implications for Lexical OrganizationBrain and Language, 2000
- Verb Retrieval in Brain-Damaged Subjects: 2. Analysis of ErrorsBrain and Language, 2000
- Semantic Factors in Verb Retrieval: An Effect of ComplexityBrain and Language, 1998
- Ideational Gestures and Speech in Brain-damaged SubjectsLanguage and Cognitive Processes, 1998
- An impairment in processing verbs' thematic roles: A therapy studyAphasiology, 1997
- Agrammatic and non-brain-damaged subjects' verb and verb argument structure productionAphasiology, 1997
- Verb Retrieval in Aphasia. 1. Characterizing Single Word ImpairmentsBrain and Language, 1997
- Model-guided treatment to improve written sentence production: A case studyAphasiology, 1993
- Some aspects of sentence production in aphasiaAphasiology, 1989
- Sentence processing deficits: Theory and therapyCognitive Neuropsychology, 1988