Null subjects and polarity focus*
- 14 November 2007
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Studia Linguistica
- Vol. 61 (3) , 212-236
Abstract
Abstract. Some null‐subject languages cannot drop the subject pronoun in the second conjunct in sentences which translate asThey say that John doesn’t speak French, but he does, where the pronoun is coreferent with John. Among the null‐subject languages which do not allow a null subject in this context are Chinese (various dialects), Finnish and European Portuguese. Among the languages that allow it are Japanese, Persian, and Spanish. An explanation is proposed of this variation, based on the following correlation: The languages which do not allow a null subject standardly reply to yes/no‐questions by repeating the finite verb of the question. The languages which allow a null subject standardly reply by using a special affirmation particle ‘yes’. The connection between these two properties is that both involve polarity focus. The proposal is that a null subject in the second conjunct is prohibited in the former class because of a competition of derivations involving ellipsis. This hypothesis is based on the theory of polarity focus in Finnish articulated inHolmberg (2001).Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Emphatic Affirmation and Polarity2006
- Is There a Little Pro? Evidence from FinnishLinguistic Inquiry, 2005
- Accessibility theory2001
- The syntax of yes and no in FinnishStudia Linguistica, 2001
- The Welsh Answering System1999
- Empty Subjects in Finnish and HebrewNatural Language & Linguistic Theory, 1999
- Enclisis, VP-deletion and the nature of SigmaProbus, 1994
- Case and Other Functional Categories in Finnish Syntax1993
- Pro-Drop in Chinese: A Generalized Control Theory1989
- The Null Subject Parameter and Parametric Theory1989