The Reasonableness Standard for Conscientious Objection in Healthcare
- 1 February 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Bioethical Inquiry
- Vol. 19 (2) , 255-264
Abstract
In complex, pluralistic societies, different views concerning the moral duties of healthcare professionals inevitably exist: according to some accounts, doctors can and should cooperate in performing abortion or physician-assisted suicide, while according to others they should always defend human life and protect their patients’ health. It is argued that the very plurality of responses presently given to questions such as these provides a liberal argument in favour of conscientious objection (CO), as an attempt to deal with moral diversity by protecting both the professionals’ claim to moral integrity and the patients’ claim to receive lawful and safe medical treatments. A moderate view on CO is defended, according to which none of these claims can be credited with unconditional value. Claims to CO by healthcare professionals can be justified but must be subjected to a reasonableness standard. Both the incompatibility of CO with the medical profession and its unconditional sanctioning by conscience absolutism are therefore rejected. The paper contributes to the definition of the conditions of such reasonableness, particularly by stressing the role played by conceptions of good medicine in discriminating claims to CO; it is argued that respecting these conditions prevents from having the negative consequences dreaded by critics. The objection according to which accepting the physician’s duty to inform and refer is inconsistent with the professed value of moral integrity is also discussed.Keywords
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- Why medical professionals have no moral claim to conscientious objection accommodation in liberal democraciesJournal of Medical Ethics, 2016
- A Defence of Conscientious Objection in Medicine: A Reply to Schuklenk and SavulescuBioethics, 2015
- Conscientious Objection in Medicine: Private Ideological Convictions must not Supercede Public Service ObligationsBioethics, 2015
- Reasonability and Conscientious Objection in Medicine: A Reply to Marsh and an Elaboration of the Reason‐Giving RequirementBioethics, 2013
- When should conscientious objection be accepted?Journal of Medical Ethics, 2011
- Conscientious Objection Gone Awry — Restoring Selfless Professionalism in MedicineNew England Journal of Medicine, 2009
- Conscientious refusal by physicians and pharmacists: who is obligated to do what, and why?Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics, 2008
- Conscientious Objection and Emergency ContraceptionThe American Journal of Bioethics, 2007
- Conscientious objection in medicineBMJ, 2006
- The Limits of Conscientious Objection — May Pharmacists Refuse to Fill Prescriptions for Emergency Contraception?New England Journal of Medicine, 2004