What Do Proofreaders of Student Writing Do to a Master’s Essay? Differing Interventions, Worrying Findings
Author:
- 19 July 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Written Communication
- Vol. 35 (4) , 474-530
Abstract
There has been much interest recently in researching the changes editors, supervisors, and other language brokers make to the writing of L2 researchers who are attempting to publish in English. However, studies focused on the presubmission proofreading of students’ university essays are rarer. In this study of student proofreading, 14 UK university proofreaders all proofread the same authentic, low-quality master’s essay written by an L2 speaker of English to enable a comparison of interventions. Proofreaders explained their interventions by means of a talk aloud while proofreading and at a post-proofreading interview. Quantitative and qualitative analysis of the data reveals evidence of widely differing practices and beliefs, with the number of interventions ranging from 113 to 472. Some proofreaders intervened at the level of content, making lengthy suggestions to improve the writer’s essay structure and argumentation, while others were reluctant to do more than focus on the language. Disturbingly, some proofreaders introduced errors into the text while leaving the writer’s errors uncorrected. I conclude that the results are cause for deep concern for universities striving to formulate ethical proofreading policies.Keywords
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- “Convenience editors” as legitimate participants in the practice of scientific editing: An interview studyJournal of English for Academic Purposes, 2013
- “Convenience Editing” in action: Comparing English teachers’ and medical professionals’ revisions of a medical abstractEnglish for Specific Purposes, 2012
- “I have no time to find out where the sentences came from; I just rebuild them”: A biochemistry professor eliminating novices’ textual borrowingJournal of Second Language Writing, 2012
- Cleaner, helper, teacher? The role of proofreaders of student writingStudies in Higher Education, 2011
- Mark my words: the role of assessment criteria in UK higher education grading practicesStudies in Higher Education, 2011
- Guidelines for the editing of dissertations and theses: A survey of editors’ perceptionsSouthern African Linguistics and Applied Language Studies, 2010
- Ethics and integrity in proofreading: Findings from an interview-based studyEnglish for Specific Purposes, 2010
- Professional Editing Strategies Used by Six EditorsWritten Communication, 2007
- The Reliability and Validity of Protocol AnalysisWritten Communication, 1989
- The Idea of a Writing CenterCollege English, 1984