Evaluation and Comparison of ICESat-2 and GEDI Data for Terrain and Canopy Height Retrievals in Short-Stature Vegetation
Open Access
- 15 October 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Remote Sensing
- Vol. 15 (20) , 4969
Abstract
Two space-borne light detection and ranging (LiDAR) missions, Global Ecosystem Dynamics Investigation (GEDI) and Ice, Cloud, and land Elevation Satellite-2 (ICESat-2), have demonstrated high capabilities in extracting terrain and canopy heights in forest environments. However, there have been limited studies evaluating their performance for terrain and canopy height retrievals in short-stature vegetation. This study utilizes airborne LiDAR data to validate and compare the accuracies of terrain and canopy height retrievals for short-stature vegetation using the latest versions of ICESat-2 (Version 5) and GEDI (Version 2). Furthermore, this study also analyzes the influence of various factors, such as vegetation type, terrain slope, canopy height, and canopy cover, on terrain and canopy height retrievals. The results indicate that ICESat-2 (bias = −0.05 m, RMSE = 0.67 m) outperforms GEDI (bias = 0.39 m, RMSE = 1.40 m) in terrain height extraction, with similar results observed for canopy height retrievals from both missions. Additionally, the findings reveal significant differences in terrain and canopy height retrieval accuracies between ICESat-2 and GEDI data under different data acquisition scenarios. Error analysis results demonstrate that terrain slope plays a pivotal role in influencing the accuracy of terrain height extraction for both missions, particularly for GEDI data, where the terrain height accuracy decreases significantly with increasing terrain slope. However, canopy height has the most substantial impact on the estimation accuracies of GEDI and ICESat-2 canopy heights. Overall, these findings confirm the strong potential of ICESat-2 data for terrain and canopy height retrievals in short-stature vegetation areas, and also provide valuable insights for future applications of space-borne LiDAR data in short-stature vegetation-dominated ecosystems.Keywords
Funding Information
- Open Research Fund of the Key Laboratory of Digital Earth Science, Aerospace Information Research Institute, Chinese Academy of Sciences (2022LDE002, OFSLRSS202313, 42171352, 42171369, 2019130, IGCEA2224)
- the Open Fund of the State Key Laboratory of Remote Sensing Science (2022LDE002, OFSLRSS202313, 42171352, 42171369, 2019130, IGCEA2224)
- National Natural Science Foundation of China (2022LDE002, OFSLRSS202313, 42171352, 42171369, 2019130, IGCEA2224)
- Youth Innovation Promotion Association of the Chinese Academy of Sciences (2022LDE002, OFSLRSS202313, 42171352, 42171369, 2019130, IGCEA2224)
- National Nonprofit Fundamental Research Grant of China, Institute of Geology, China Earthquake Administration (2022LDE002, OFSLRSS202313, 42171352, 42171369, 2019130, IGCEA2224)
This publication has 42 references indexed in Scilit:
- Combining high-resolution images and LiDAR data to model ecosystem services perception in compact urban systemsEcological Indicators, 2019
- Spaceborne Lidar in the Study of Marine SystemsAnnual Review of Marine Science, 2018
- Airborne lidar remote sensing applications in non-forested short stature environments: a reviewAnnals of Forest Research, 2017
- A revised terrain correction method for forest canopy height estimation using ICESat/GLAS dataISPRS Journal of Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, 2015
- Advances in animal ecology from 3D-LiDAR ecosystem mappingTrends in Ecology & Evolution, 2014
- Estimation of forest aboveground biomass in California using canopy height and leaf area index estimated from satellite dataRemote Sensing of Environment, 2014
- Lidar sampling for large-area forest characterization: A reviewRemote Sensing of Environment, 2012
- A global forest canopy height map from the Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer and the Geoscience Laser Altimeter SystemGeophysical Research Letters, 2010
- NEON: the first continental-scale ecological observatory with airborne remote sensing of vegetation canopy biochemistry and structureJournal of Applied Remote Sensing, 2010
- The Shuttle Radar Topography MissionReviews of Geophysics, 2007