From Policy to Personality: How Americans Evaluate Presidential Candidates, 1984–2020
Author:
- 23 September 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in American Politics Research
- Vol. 55 (1) , 26-42
Abstract
This study examines how American voters’ articulated standards for evaluating presidential candidates have changed over time. Using open-ended “likes” and “dislikes” from the American National Election Studies (ANES) from 1984 to 2020, I analyze the criteria citizens invoke and how broadly they evaluate nominees in their own words. I extend ANES’s likes/dislikes coding – which classifies responses into nine evaluative categories spanning policy, party, candidate traits, governance, and other considerations – to recent elections using new human labels and a BERT-based classifier, enabling consistent classification across the full time series. The analysis focuses on three dimensions of expressed evaluation: evaluative content, evaluative breadth, and cross-party evaluative overlap. The results reveal a long-run transformation in articulated electoral judgment. Personal qualities expand sharply to become the dominant evaluative dimension, while policy-based considerations – especially domestic policy – decline in relative prominence. At the same time, evaluative breadth contracts, with respondents articulating fewer distinct criteria per candidate even after accounting for respondent characteristics and interview mode. Finally, cross-party comparison narrows as shared evaluative standards decline and become increasingly concentrated in personal qualities rather than policy. A party-evaluation placebo shows that these patterns are not reducible to generalized open-ended survey fatigue. These patterns indicate that contemporary articulated candidate evaluation is thinner, more personalized, and less anchored in shared programmatic benchmarks, suggesting a narrowing foundation for commensurable electoral accountability in American presidential elections.Keywords
This publication has 36 references indexed in Scilit:
- Reassessing the structure of presidential characterElectoral Studies, 2018
- Face Value? Experimental Evidence that Candidate Appearance Influences Electoral ChoicePolitical Behavior, 2016
- Independent Politics2016
- Political leaders and the media. Can we measure political leadership images in newspapers using computer-assisted content analysis?Quality & Quantity, 2015
- The personalization of politics in Western democracies: Causes and consequences on leader–follower relationshipsThe Leadership Quarterly, 2011
- Has Television Personalized Voting Behavior?Political Behavior, 2008
- Post-Broadcast Democracy2007
- Hearing the Other Side2006
- The New Videomalaise: Effects of Televised Incivility on Political TrustAmerican Political Science Review, 2005
- Congress as Public Enemy1995