Identifying Stakeholders' Views on Sustainable Urban Transition: Desirability, Utility and Probability Assessments of Scenarios
- 13 September 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in European Planning Studies
- Vol. 20 (10) , 1667-1687
Abstract
The assessment of different urban planning scenarios by stakeholders can yield important insights which, in turn, inform sustainable urban transition. Yet to gain in-depth insight, this assessment needs to be multi-faceted and should go beyond a unidimensional “most/least desired” approach. Accordingly, we use indicators that distinguish between desirability, utility and probability assessments. We compare these assessments within and between various stakeholder groups based on a set of literature-based hypotheses. We constructed six planning scenarios, systematically varied with respect to sustainability for the case study, “Erlenmatt”, a major urban redevelopment area in Switzerland. Three stakeholder groups (housing suppliers, the non-profit & public sector and housing target groups, n = 80) were investigated. The results of the statistical analyses suggest that more sustainable scenarios are preferred with respect to both their desirability and utility and that their probability is not lower than that of the other scenarios. The non-profit & public sector is the most pessimistic about the probability of a sustainable district while housing suppliers desire it less. We conclude that such detailed subjective scenario assessments can provide informative and detailed guidance for sustainable urban transition.Keywords
This publication has 49 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Disconnected Innovation of New Urbanity in Zuidas Amsterdam, Ørestad Copenhagen and Forum BarcelonaEuropean Planning Studies, 2009
- Spatial Strategic Planning in the Stockholm Region—Discourses on the Space-economy and Growth FactorsEuropean Planning Studies, 2009
- Planners' Role: Torn between Dialogical Ideals and Neo-liberal RealitiesEuropean Planning Studies, 2009
- Rethinking Sustainable Urban Regeneration: Ambiguity, Creativity, and the Shared TerritoryEnvironment and Planning A: Economy and Space, 2008
- Managing Transition in Clusters: Area Development Negotiations as a Tool for Sustaining Traditional Industries in a Swiss Prealpine RegionEnvironment and Planning A: Economy and Space, 2007
- System Innovation in Spatial Development: Current Dutch ApproachesEuropean Planning Studies, 2007
- Sustainable Future Urban Mobility: Using ‘Area Development Negotiations’ for Scenario Assessment and Participatory Strategic PlanningEnvironment and Planning A: Economy and Space, 2004
- City management and urban environmental indicatorsEcological Economics, 2002
- Positioning Planning in a Market EconomyEnvironment and Planning A: Economy and Space, 1998
- The case that the world has reached limits: More precisely that current throughput growth in the global economy cannot be sustainedPopulation and Environment, 1992