Indigenous Influence and Engagement in Mining Permitting in British Columbia, Canada: Lessons for Sweden and Norway?
Open Access
- 26 October 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Environmental Management
- Vol. 72 (1) , 1-18
Abstract
Mine developments in Indigenous territories risk disrupting Indigenous cultures and their economies, including spiraling already high levels of conflict. This is the situation in Canada, Sweden, and Norway, as elsewhere, and is fostered by current state legal framework that reflect historical trajectories, although circumstances are gradually changing. Promising institutional changes have taken place in British Columbia (BC), Canada, with respect to new legislative reforms. Notably, new legislation from 2019 intends to implement the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP) in the province, by promoting consent-based and collaborative decision-making mechanisms. New environmental assessment legislation is another example; this legislation includes early engagement, collaborative decision-making, and Indigenous-led assessments. The article’s aim is, first, to analyze how Indigenous communities can influence and engage in the mining permitting system of BC, and, secondly, to highlight the positive features of the BC system using a comparative lens to identify opportunities for Sweden and Norway regarding mining permitting and Indigenous rights. Applying a legal-scientific and comparative analysis, the article analyzes traditional legal sources. The article concludes that the strong points that the BC regime could offer the two Nordic countries are: the concept of reconciliation, incorporation of UNDRIP, the spectrum of consultation and engagement approaches, and the structure of environmental assessments. All three jurisdictions, however, struggle with balancing mine developments and securing Indigenous authority and influence over land uses in their traditional territories.Keywords
Funding Information
- Norges Forskningsråd (No. 259418)
- VINNOVA (2017-02226)
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Rationale for the Duty to Consult Indigenous Peoples: Comparative Reflections from Nordic and Canadian Legal ContextsArctic Review on Law and Politics, 2018
- “Legalizing” the Great Bear Rainforest Agreements: Colonial Adaptations Toward Reconciliation and ConservationMcgill Law Journal / Revue de Droit de Mcgill, 2018
- ‘I live off this land:’ Tahltan women and activism in northern British ColumbiaWomen's History Review, 2017
- Do indigenous interests have a say in planning of new mining projects? Experiences from Finnmark, NorwayThe Extractive Industries and Society, 2016
- Legal Protection of Sami Traditional Livelihoods from the Adverse Impacts of Mining: A Comparison of the Level of Protection Enjoyed by Sami in Their Four Home StatesArctic Review on Law and Politics, 2015
- Mining Sapmi: Colonial Histories, Sami Archaeology, and the Exploitation of Natural Resources in Northern SwedenArctic Anthropology, 2015
- Sub‐surface Property, Free‐entry Mineral Staking and Settler Colonialism in CanadaAntipode, 2014
- Sharing the colonial burden: Treaty‐making and reconciliation in Hul’qumi’num territoryCanadian Geographies / Géographies canadiennes, 2012
- An environmental justice analysis of caribou recovery planning, protection of an Indigenous culture, and coal mining development in northeast British Columbia, CanadaEnvironment, Development and Sustainability, 2011
- Increasing the sustainability of a resource development: Aboriginal engagement and negotiated agreementsEnvironment, Development and Sustainability, 2009