Open Access
- 8 July 2025
- journal article
- Published by IOP Publishing in Environmental Research Letters
- Vol. 20 (8) , 084042
Abstract
A protein transition is promoted as a pathway toward a sustainable food system, but its application and progress are potentially hindered by diverse, often conflicting narratives among various stakeholders. These narratives are constituted and underpinned by statements and nurture a growing polarisation by isolation of their underlying scientific evidence. The multidimensional and interdisciplinary nature of a protein transition does not go well with an isolated approach in academia. The latter leads to fragmented and incomplete scientific evidence that fails to fully grasp the complexity of the issue, while being used to form partial statements that feed societal and political debates. Through a Restatement approach, this paper aims to (i) synthesise scientific evidence from multiple academic disciplines related to a protein transition and (ii) critically reflect on the implications of the current fragmented scientific evidence landscape of a protein transition in academia and beyond. The Restatement is structured into three sections: Background, Context, and Impacts, with subsections that each cover 4–17 statements, with a total of 68 statements. We connected each statement to its supporting scientific evidence which revealed the complexity of how evidence is related and interpreted, in addition to the inconsistent use of terminology and resulting ambiguities. The main takeaway from the Restatement is that a protein transition cannot be reduced to a single message of a dietary shift but that it should be approached more holistically, while using the available evidence within the appropriate context and critical consideration of the methodologies used to obtain that evidence. This Restatement can be used by researchers and decision-makers working toward more sustainable food systems in the European Union and beyond, to understand the contexts and methods that are not within their own field of expertise. In addition, we stress that overcoming polarisation in a protein transition largely relies on critical reflections of the assumptions, interests and power dynamics shaping the protein transition debate.Keywords
Funding Information
- Mistra Food Futures (DIA 2018/24)
This publication has 77 references indexed in Scilit:
- A review of policy levers to reduce meat production and consumptionAppetite, 2024
- Are Animals Needed for Food Supply, Efficient Resource Use, and Sustainable Cropping Systems? An Argumentation Analysis Regarding Livestock FarmingFood Ethics, 2024
- Explaining differences in research utilization in evidence-based government ministriesPolicy Sciences, 2024
- ‘Getting the Right Nutrients to Those Who Need Them Most’: towards nutrition-sensitive governance of fisheries in the Global SouthReviews in Fish Biology and Fisheries, 2022
- Climate change and food security in selected Sub-Saharan African CountriesEnvironment, Development and Sustainability, 2022
- Review: Why and how to regulate animal production and consumption: The case of the European UnionAnimal, 2021
- How food systems change (or not): governance implications for system transformation processesFood Security, 2021
- The climate responsibilities of industrial meat and dairy producersClimatic Change, 2021
- Palatable disruption: the politics of plant milkAgriculture and Human Values, 2020
- Transitions to sustainability: a change in thinking about food systems change?Agriculture and Human Values, 2014