Postdigital Peer Review: A Vulnerable Space Between Freedom and Responsibility

Authors:
  • GVGeorge Veletsianos
    George Veletsianos
  • GAGalyna Arabadzhy
    Galyna Arabadzhy
  • VAVarun Athilat
    Varun Athilat
  • JBJohn Bartucz
    John Bartucz
  • SDShreepriya Dogra
    Shreepriya Dogra
  • NFNeal R. Fredrickson
    Neal R. Fredrickson
  • MGMegan Goeke
    Megan Goeke
  • SJSeeun Tina Jeon
    Seeun Tina Jeon
  • MUMya Urena
    Mya Urena
  • PJPetar Jandrić
    Petar Jandrić
  • BGBenjamin J. Green
    Benjamin J. Green
  • LJLiz Jackson
    Liz Jackson

Abstract
While academic peer review is the cornerstone of scholarly publishing, it presents significant challenges for early-career researchers. This collective paper describes an authentic peer review experience within a doctoral seminar. In collaboration with Postdigital Science and Education , students acted as peer reviewers for manuscripts under consideration, wrote individual reflections on the process, and engaged in group discussions to analyze their experiences. Students grappled with questions of expertise, the challenge of providing constructive criticism, the ‘hidden curriculum’ of academic publishing, and the need for clearer reviewer guidelines. These insights are then discussed and expanded by seasoned scholars in the field, with the goal of a transparent and iterative dialogue that strengthens scholarly communities.

This publication has 40 references indexed in Scilit: