Richard Owen, William Whewell, and the Vestiges
Author:
- 1 July 1977
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in The British Journal for the History of Science
- Vol. 10 (2) , 132-145
Abstract
In The life of Richard Owen by his grandson there is an inference to the effect that Owen had objected to his name being used to authorize various statements that Whewell was drafting in opposition to the Vestiges. The inference is drawn from letters that Whewell wrote to Owen on 13 and 15 February 1845. Corroboration of this would corne from a letter of Owen to Whewell, dated 14 February 1845, if extant. Among the Whewell papers at Trinity College, Cambridge, there are several letters from Owen to Whewell, none of which bears that date. There is one, however, dated 14 February 1844 which, on doser inspection, turns out to be the missing link in their correspondance. The evidence for the misdating is not merely that the letter falls naturally into a later sequence. The conclusion is inescapable because Owen refers to an ‘opinion which I have always entertained, and still do strongly, on the subject of a refutation of “Vestiges”’. Since the first edition of Chambers's book did not appear until October 1844, the letter must belong to the following year. My object in this paper is to examine the implications of this letter for a reconstruction of Owen's attitude to that book which Adam Sedgwick could so detest for, among many things, its ‘gross (and I dare to say, filthy) views of physiology’.Keywords
This publication has 7 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Relationship between Science and Religion in Britain, 1830–1870Church History, 1975
- The Universal gestation of nature: Chambers'Vestiges andExplanationsJournal of the History of Biology, 1972
- Vestiges of the natural history of creationStudies in History and Philosophy of Science, 1970
- Evolutionism and Richard Owen, 1830-1868: An Episode in Darwin's CenturyIsis, 1965
- The life of Richard Owen1894
- On the nature of limbs1849
- XXXIV.—Description of a fossil molar tooth of a Mastodon discovered by Count Strzlecki in AustraliaAnnals and Magazine of Natural History, 1844