Do managers capture the value they create? Drivers of managers' value capture in a large retail chain
Authors:
- 1 April 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Strategic Management Journal
- Vol. 43 (10) , 1983-2011
Abstract
Research Summary: We investigate the relationship between value creation and value capture among frontline managers. Using longitudinal data from a restaurant chain, we find that those managers who persistently create more value for the firm capture just 0.5% of that extra value through their pay. We explore the reasons for this limited managerial value capture using an abductive approach. We find some evidence that value capture may be limited by lack of alternative employment opportunities. More extensive evidence suggests that the employer often struggled to identify individual contributions to value creation, limiting managerial rewards. We discuss the theoretical implications of such limited managerial value capture for the strategic human capital literature. Managerial Summary: Frontline managers can differ in how much they contribute to firm profitability. Do those managers who contribute the most to firm performance also capture those benefits back through higher pay? In a study of restaurant managers, we find that managers differ substantially in the profits that they create, but that the most profitable managers only capture 0.5% of the extra profits they create. We also find evidence that the firm often fails to identify which managers are the most persistently profitable, potentially reducing the rewards paid to those managers. By demonstrating that differences in performance are not balanced by differences in pay, we show how high‐performing managers can be an important strategic resource for organizations.Keywords
Funding Information
- Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM Foundation Dissertation Grant Award)
This publication has 66 references indexed in Scilit:
- Rethinking Sustained Competitive Advantage from Human CapitalAcademy of Management Review, 2012
- The Impact of Causal Ambiguity on Competitive Advantage and Rent AppropriationBritish Journal of Management, 2010
- Envy, comparison costs, and the economic theory of the firmStrategic Management Journal, 2008
- Business segment performance redux: a multilevel approachStrategic Management Journal, 2005
- What Trade-off of Risk and Incentives?American Economic Review, 2000
- Are CEOs Really Paid Like Bureaucrats?The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 1998
- Middle Management’s Strategic Influence and Organizational PerformanceJournal of Management Studies, 1997
- Why Do Employers Only Reward Extreme Performance? Examining the Relationships Among Performance, Pay, and TurnoverAdministrative Science Quarterly, 1992
- Toward a Theory of Mobility and Behavior in Organizations: An Inquiry Into the Consequences of Some Relationships Between Individual Performance and Organizational SuccessAmerican Journal of Sociology, 1981
- Experience, Performance, and EarningsThe Quarterly Journal of Economics, 1980