International Trade and Investment Agreements as Barriers to Food Environment Regulation for Public Health Nutrition: A Realist Review
Open Access
- 19 October 2020
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Maad Rayan Publishing Company in International Journal of Health Policy and Management
- Vol. 10 (12) , 745-765
Abstract
Background: Achieving healthy food systems will require regulation across the supply chain; however, binding international economic agreements may be constraining policy space for regulatory intervention in a way that limits uptake of ‘best-practice’ nutrition policy. A deeper understanding of the mechanisms through which this occurs, and under which conditions, can inform public health engagement with the economic policy sector. Methods: We conducted a realist review of nutrition, policy and legal literature to identify mechanisms through which international trade and investment agreements (TIAs) constrain policy space for priority food environment regulations to prevent non-communicable diseases (NCDs). Recommended regulations explored include fiscal policies, product bans, nutrition labelling, advertising restrictions, nutrient composition regulations, and procurement policies. The process involved 5 steps: initial conceptual framework development; search for relevant empirical literature; study selection and appraisal; data extraction; analysis and synthesis, and framework revision. Results: Twenty-six studies and 30 institutional records of formal trade/investment disputes or specific trade concerns (STCs) raised were included. We identified 13 cases in which TIA constraints on nutrition policy space could be observed. Significant constraints on nutrition policy space were documented with respect to fiscal policies, product bans, and labelling policies in 4 middle-income country jurisdictions, via 3 different TIAs. In 7 cases, trade-related concerns were raised but policies were ultimately preserved. Two of the included cases were ongoing at the time of analysis. TIAs constrained policy space through 1) TIA rules and principles (non- discrimination, necessity, international standards, transparency, intellectual property rights, expropriation, and fair and equitable treatment), and 2) interaction with policy design (objectives framed, products/services affected, nutrient thresholds chosen, formats, and time given to comment or implement). Contextual factors of importance included: actors/institutions, and political/regulatory context. Conclusion: Available evidence suggests that there are potential TIA contributors to policy inertia on nutrition. Strategic policy design can avoid most substantive constraints. However, process constraints in the name of good regulatory practice (investor-state dispute settlement (ISDS), transparency, regulatory coherence, and harmonisation) pose a more serious threat of reducing government policy space to enact healthy food policies.Keywords
This publication has 52 references indexed in Scilit:
- The influence of market deregulation on fast food consumption and body mass index: a cross-national time series analysisBulletin of the World Health Organization, 2014
- Protecting policy space for public health nutrition in an era of international investment agreementsBulletin of the World Health Organization, 2013
- Ultra‐processed products are becoming dominant in the global food systemObesity Reviews, 2013
- How Do International Trade Obligations Affect Policy Options for Obesity Prevention? Lessons from Recent Developments in Trade and Tobacco ControlCanadian Journal of Diabetes, 2013
- Profits and pandemics: prevention of harmful effects of tobacco, alcohol, and ultra-processed food and drink industriesThe Lancet, 2013
- Changes in Diet and Lifestyle and Long-Term Weight Gain in Women and MenNew England Journal of Medicine, 2011
- Salt intake, stroke, and cardiovascular disease: meta-analysis of prospective studiesBMJ, 2009
- Dietary Sugars Intake and Cardiovascular HealthCirculation, 2009
- Sugar-sweetened beverages and BMI in children and adolescents: reanalyses of a meta-analysisThe American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 2009
- Realist review - a new method of systematic review designed for complex policy interventionsJournal of Health Services Research & Policy, 2005