Critical Theory and the Paradox of Discourse
Author:
- 1 March 1995
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in The American Review of Public Administration
- Vol. 25 (1) , 1-19
Abstract
The work of public administration theorists who argue for a broader sphere of administrative discretion falls into three broad paradigms: the legitimacy paradigm, the guardian paradigm, and the critical paradigm. Legitimacy theorists argue for recognition within the Constitutional framework, and guardian theorists argue for more discretion for administrators to govern for the uninformed public. Neither view has much practical impact because neither fits American attitudes toward government. The critical paradigm advocates providing citizens with information so they may take action and free themselves from domination by elites. This critical view involves less, rather than more, formal power for professional administrators and puts them at odds with the elected officials who employ them. The paper seeks to determine whether this view of the role of the public administrator accurately portrays the nature of the relationship between citizens and government and whether the public administrator can be an effective agent of change by becoming an information provider instead of seeking greater institutional power.Keywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- Toward a More Perfect UnionPublic Administration Review, 1993
- Legitimacy, History, and Logic: Public Administration and the ConstitutionPublic Administration Review, 1993
- Rationality and Romanticism in Constitutional ArgumentPublic Administration Review, 1993
- We Have Debated Ad Nauseam the Legitimacy of the Administrative State-But Why?Public Administration Review, 1993
- The Administrator as Trustee of the Public InterestAdministration & Society, 1992
- What do we Mean When we Say "Professionalism?": A Language Usage Analysis for Public AdministrationThe American Review of Public Administration, 1992
- Diminishing UtilityUrban Affairs Review, 1990
- The Growth Machine versus the Antigrowth CoalitionUrban Affairs Review, 1989
- On the Growth of Knowledge in Public AdministrationPublic Administration Review, 1986
- The Twilight of Hierarchy: Speculations on the Global Information SocietyPublic Administration Review, 1985