A Descriptive Comparison of Ultrasound‐guided Central Venous Cannulation of the Internal Jugular Vein to Landmark‐based Subclavian Vein Cannulation
Open Access
- 2 April 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Academic Emergency Medicine
- Vol. 17 (4) , 416-422
Abstract
Objectives: The safest site for central venous cannulation (CVC) remains debated. Many emergency physicians (EPs) advocate the ultrasound‐guided internal jugular (USIJ) approach because of data supporting its efficiency. However, a number of physicians prefer, and are most comfortable with, the subclavian (SC) vein approach. The purpose of this study was to describe adverse event rates among operators using the USIJ approach, and the landmark SC vein approach without US.Methods: This was a prospective observational trial of patients undergoing CVC of the SC or internal jugular veins in the emergency department (ED). Physicians performing the procedures did not undergo standardized training in either technique. The primary outcome was a composite of adverse events defined as hematoma, arterial cannulation, pneumothorax, and failure to cannulate. Physicians recorded the anatomical site of cannulation, US assistance, indications, and acute complications. Variables of interest were collected from the pharmacy and ED record. Physician experience was based on a self‐reported survey. The authors followed outcomes of central line insertion until device removal or patient discharge.Results: Physicians attempted 236 USIJ and 132 SC cannulations on 333 patients. The overall adverse event rate was 22% with failure to cannulate being the most common. Adverse events occurred in 19% of USIJ attempts, compared to 29% of non–US‐guided SC attempts. Among highly experienced operators, CVCs placed at the SC site resulted in more adverse events than those performed using USIJ (relative risk [RR] = 1.89, 95% confidence interval [CI] = 1.05 to 3.39).Conclusions: While limited by observational design, our results suggest that the USIJ technique may result in fewer adverse events compared to the landmark SC approach.ACADEMIC EMERGENCY MEDICINE 2010; 17:416–422 © 2010 by the Society for Academic Emergency MedicineKeywords
This publication has 29 references indexed in Scilit:
- Central venous catheterisation: internal jugular or subclavian approach?Emergency Medicine Journal, 2007
- Real-Time Ultrasonographically-Guided Internal Jugular Vein Catheterization in the Emergency Department Increases Success Rates and Reduces Complications: A Randomized, Prospective StudyAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 2006
- Development and Validation of a Scale for the Clarity of Anatomical Landmarks for Use in Outcomes Research of Ultrasound Guidance of Central Venous CannulationAcademic Emergency Medicine, 2006
- Randomized Controlled Trial of Single-Operator vs. Two-Operator Ultrasound Guidance for Internal Jugular Central Venous CannulationAcademic Emergency Medicine, 2006
- Ultrasonography in Community Emergency Departments in the United States: Access to Ultrasonography Performed by Consultants and Status of Emergency Physician-Performed UltrasonographyAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 2006
- Is routine ultrasound guidance for central line placement beneficial? A prospective analysisCurrent Surgery, 2004
- Ultrasound Guidance versus the Landmark Technique for the Placement of Central Venous Catheters in the Emergency DepartmentAcademic Emergency Medicine, 2002
- Subclavian venous catheterizationCritical Care Medicine, 1995
- Prospective Evaluation of Central Venous Pressure (CVP) Catheters in a Large City-County HospitalAnnals of Surgery, 1982
- Choice of route for central venous cannulation: Subclavian or internal jugular vein? A prospective randomized studyJournal of Surgical Oncology, 1981