Check your data before you wreck your model: The impact of careless responding on substance use data quality
Authors:
- Abby L. BraitmanABAbby L. Braitman
- Anna M. PetreyAPAnna M. Petrey
- Jennifer L. ShipleyJSJennifer L. Shipley
- Rachel Ayala GuzmanRGRachel Ayala Guzman
- Alison LoobyALAlison Looby
- Adrian J. BravoABAdrian J. Bravo
- Stimulant Norms and Prevalence 2 (SNAP2) Study TeamSTStimulant Norms and Prevalence 2 (SNAP2) Study Team
Open Access
- 16 March 2025
- journal article
- special topics
- Published by Wiley in Alcohol, Clinical and Experimental Research
- Vol. 49 (4) , 941-951
Abstract
Background: The accuracy of survey responses is a concern in research data quality, especially in college student samples. However, examination of the impact of removing participants from analyses who respond inaccurately or carelessly is warranted given the potential for loss of information or sample diversity. This study aimed to understand if careless responding varies across a number of demographic indices, substance use behaviors, and the timing of survey completion.Method: College students (N = 5809; 70.7% female; 75.7% White, non‐Hispanic) enrolled in psychology classes from six universities completed an online survey assessing a variety of demographic and substance use‐related information, which included four attention check questions dispersed throughout the hour‐long survey. Differences in careless responding were assessed across multiple demographic groups, and we examined the impact of careless responding on data quality via a confirmatory factor analysis of a validated substance use measure, the Drinking Motives Questionnaire‐Revised Short Form.Results: Careless responding varied significantly by participant race, sex, gender, sexual orientation, and socioeconomic status. Substance use was generally unassociated with careless responding, though careless responding was associated with experiencing more alcohol‐related problems. Careless responding was more prevalent when the survey was completed near the end of the semester. Finally, the factor structure of the drinking motives measure was affected by the inclusion of those who failed two or more attention check questions.Conclusions: Including attention checks in surveys is an effective method to detect and address careless responding. However, omitting participants from analyses who evidence any careless responding may bias the sample demographics. We discuss recommendations for the use of attention check questions in undergraduate substance use cross‐sectional surveys, including retaining participants who fail only one attention check, as this has a minimal impact on data quality while preserving sample diversity.Keywords
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- Careless responding in online studies is associated with alcohol use: A mega-analysis.Psychology of Addictive Behaviors, 2024
- How do social and economic status impact measurement error?International Journal of Social Research Methodology, 2022
- The neglected 95% revisited: Is American psychology becoming less American?American Psychologist, 2021
- Negative alcohol-related consequences experienced by young adults in the past 12 months: Differences by college attendance, living situation, binge drinking, and sexAddictive Behaviors, 2020
- Research SynthesisPublic Opinion Quarterly, 2019
- Caring about carelessness: Participant inattention and its effects on researchJournal of Research in Personality, 2014
- Dimensions and severity of marijuana consequences: Development and validation of the Marijuana Consequences Questionnaire (MACQ)Addictive Behaviors, 2012
- Development and Validation of the Drinking Motive Questionnaire Revised Short Form (DMQ–R SF)Journal of Clinical Child & Adolescent Psychology, 2009
- Toward Efficient and Comprehensive Measurement of the Alcohol Problems Continuum in College Students: The Brief Young Adult Alcohol Consequences QuestionnaireAlcohol, Clinical and Experimental Research, 2005
- Cutoff criteria for fit indexes in covariance structure analysis: Conventional criteria versus new alternativesStructural Equation Modeling: A Multidisciplinary Journal, 1999