Is Weak Supplementation analytic?
Author:
Open Access
- 27 December 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Synthese
- Vol. 198 (S18) , 4229-4245
Abstract
Mereological principles are often controversial; perhaps the most stark contrast is between those who claim that Weak Supplementation is analytic—constitutive of our notion of proper parthood—and those who argue that the principle is simply false, and subject to many counterexamples. The aim of this paper is to diagnose the source of this dispute. I’ll suggest that the dispute has arisen by participants failing to be sensitive to two different conceptions of proper parthood: the outstripping conception and the non-identity conception. I’ll argue that the outstripping conception (together with a specific set of definitions for other mereological notions), can deliver the analyticity of Weak Supplementation on at least one sense of ‘analyticity’. I’ll also suggest that the non-identity conception cannot do so independently of considerations to do with mereological extensionality.Keywords
Funding Information
- Leverhulme Trust (RF-2017-046\10)
This publication has 81 references indexed in Scilit:
- Strange Parts: The Metaphysics of Non‐classical MereologiesPhilosophy Compass, 2013
- NON-WELLFOUNDED MEREOLOGYThe Review of Symbolic Logic, 2011
- Mereological Heuristics for Huayan BuddhismPhilosophy East and West, 2010
- 9. Omnipresence*2009
- Personal identity and PurgatoryReligious Studies, 2006
- Pantheism, Quantification and MereologyThe Monist, 1997
- Naive Mereology, Admissible Valuations, and Other MattersNoûs, 1993
- Mathematics in MegethologyPhilosophia Mathematica, 1993
- On Being in the Same Place at the Same TimePhilosophical Review, 1968
- Überwindung der Metaphysik durch logische Analyse der SpracheErkenntnis, 1931