Overclaiming on Personality Questionnaires

Author:
  • DPDelroy L. Paulhus
    Delroy L. Paulhus

Abstract
The over-claiming technique (OCT) is offered as a method of identifying fakers while simultaneously measuring their expertise in specific knowledge domains. The procedure is straightforward: Respondents are asked to rate their familiarity with a range of items relevant to a faking domain (e.g., academic facts, workplace items, consumer products). Knowledge accuracy is indexed by a respondent’s ability to distinguish real items from non-existent items (foils). Exaggeration can be measured either by (a) the tendency to claim familiarity with foils or (b) the overall tendency to claim familiarity. The construct validity of both the accuracy and exaggeration indexes is well-supported. They have both proved their utility in a variety of assessment contexts. Applications of the OCT currently include marketing research, educational measurement, and ethics research, as well as personnel selection.