Language-related eligibility criteria in UK randomised trials: a systematic review of extended research reports
Authors:
- Talia IsaacsTITalia Isaacs
- Andrea VaughanAVAndrea Vaughan
- Eva BurnettEBEva Burnett
- Zsófia DemjénZDZsófia Demjén
- Marie-Anne DurandMDMarie-Anne Durand
- Katie GilliesKGKatie Gillies
- Kamlesh KhuntiKKKamlesh Khunti
- Nurulamin M. NoorNurulamin M. Noor
- Frances ShielyFSFrances Shiely
- Matthew R. SydesMSMatthew R. Sydes
- Shaun TreweekSTShaun Treweek
- Katie BiggsKBKatie Biggs
Open Access
- 16 May 2026
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Springer Nature in Trials
- Vol. 27 (1)
Abstract
Background: Trial teams frequently make language-related, non-clinical eligibility decisions during recruitment. They need to ensure that patients understand the conditions and implications of trial participation and either have the necessary language skills to participate, or receive appropriate accommodations (e.g. translation or interpreting). Fair and consistent assessments are necessary to avoid unduly excluding patients, which could limit external validity and exacerbate inequalities. This study examines how trial teams make language-related eligibility decisions. Methods: We conducted a systematic review of National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) research reports (2010–2022) for UK-based randomised controlled trials (RCTs) recruiting adults for two conditions that disproportionately affect ethnic minority populations: clinical depression and type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM). Two researchers independently screened titles and abstracts and extracted data. We analysed the communication demands of the interventions and primary outcome measures in relation to how language screening was reported, including procedures or instruments used as proxies for language-related gatekeeping. Results: We assessed 185 titles and abstracts from NIHR monographs. Thirty-two RCTs (23 depression, 9 T2DM) ultimately met our inclusion criteria. Ethnic diversity was minimal, particularly in the depression RCTs, where the median proportion of White participants was 97%. Language screening practices were inconsistent across studies and were often poorly aligned with the actual linguistic demands of the trial. Half of the included RCTs explicitly reported a language-based eligibility criterion, including 63% of trials evaluating talking therapies for depression compared to 27% of trials assessing pharmacological, device-based, or surgical interventions. Explicit and implicit language-related gatekeeping measures included the ability to complete research assessments involving language (sometimes to a prespecified score cut-point), provide informed consent, and engage in the intervention as judged by recruiters. Translation and interpreting support were mentioned in one depression study. Conclusions: This review exposes methodological practices that may impede diverse patients’ participation. Linguistic demands of the interventions and outcomes need to be considered in justifying language-related screening and accommodations. Participants’ language variables need to be disentangled from ethnicity through routine data collection. A purpose-built screening tool that is universally applied to all participants could lead to fairer, more consistent assessments. Trial registration: PROSPERO International Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews CRD42021267905. https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/prospero/display_record.php?RecordID=267905 . Registered on October 21 2021.Keywords
This publication has 68 references indexed in Scilit:
- Accuracy of Artificial Intelligence vs Professionally Translated Discharge InstructionsJAMA Network Open, 2025
- A mixed-methods study on the recruitment of patients from ethnic minority groups to clinical trials in a central London teaching hospitalContemporary Clinical Trials Communications, 2025
- Most UK cardiovascular disease trial protocols feature criteria that exclude ethnic minority participants: a systematic reviewJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2024
- Limited English Proficiency as a Barrier to Inclusion in Emergency Medicine-Based Clinical Stroke ResearchJournal of Immigrant and Minority Health, 2022
- Race/ethnicity reporting and representation in US clinical trials: A cohort studyThe Lancet Regional Health - Americas, 2022
- Redressing the Balance in the Native Speaker Debate: Assessment Standards, Standard Language, and Exposing Double StandardsTESOL Quarterly, 2021
- COVID-19 and ethnicity: who will research results apply to?The Lancet, 2020
- Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions2019
- Barriers to recruiting ethnic minorities to mental health research: a systematic reviewInternational Journal of Methods in Psychiatric Research, 2014
- Wechsler Test of Adult Reading2011