The next generation of disaster financial instruments seeks to provide social protection mechanisms for the world’s most vulnerable populations and help avoid public health emergencies. Anticipatory action is designed to mobilize resources in risk-prone areas when there is a forecast for extreme weather events. In the case of drought risk, for instance, weather-index insurance can trigger payouts based on satellite-based monitoring of environmental variables and pre-agreed thresholds to speed up the availability of funds to prepare for and mitigate disasters. Such insurance models are usually designed to cover the ‘statistical tails’ of weather and climate - the most extreme events. However, there are cases where consecutive moderate to severe drought events result in socioeconomic impacts that are comparable or more severe than the impact of an isolated extreme event. Covering these consecutive events reveals unique challenges and data gaps, particularly because there is currently no socio-economic baseline that matches the granularity of available climate hazard datasets. We argue that longitudinal data collection exercises that are complementary to state-of-the-art vulnerability or food security surveys would enable researchers and index designers to explore new opportunities. A better understanding of pre-existing vulnerabilities would help to better translate non-extreme hazard information into impact estimates and predict critical socioeconomic developments more reliably. It would also support the evaluation and improvement of anticipatory financing strategies via feedback loops at household level.