Comparing precaution in the United States and Europe
Authors:
- Jonathan B. WienerJWJonathan B. Wiener
- Michael D. RogersMRMichael D. Rogers
- 1 October 2002
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Risk Research
- Vol. 5 (4) , 317-349
Abstract
The regulation of health and environmental risks has generated transatlantic controversy concerning precaution and the precautionary principle (PP). Conventional wisdom sees the European Union endorsing the PP and proactively regulating uncertain risks, while the United States opposes the PP and waits for evidence of harm before regulating. Without favouring either approach, this paper critically analyses the conventional depiction of transatlantic divergence. First, it reviews several different versions of the PP and their different implications. Second, it broadens the transatlantic comparison of precaution beyond the typical focus on single-risk examples, such as genetically modified foods. Through case studies, including hormones in beef and milk production and mad cow disease in beef and in blood donations, as well as reference to a wider array of risks, the paper demonstrates that relative precaution varies enormously. Sometimes the EU is more precautionary than the US (such as regarding hormones in beef), while sometimes the US is more precautionary than the EU (such as regarding mad cow disease in blood). Thus, neither the EU nor the US can claim to be categorically 'more precautionary' than the other. The real pattern is complex and risk-specific. Third, the paper seeks explanations for this complex pattern in five sets of hypotheses: optimal tailoring on the merits, political systems, risk perceptions, trade protectionism, and legal systems. None of these hypotheses fully explains the observed complex pattern of relative transatlantic precaution. The paper concludes that differences in relative precaution depend more on the context of the particular risk than on broad differences in national regulatory regimes.Keywords
This publication has 12 references indexed in Scilit:
- Adversarial Legalism2001
- Stars & Strife2001
- Oceans Apart? Business Responses to Global Environmental Issues in Europe and the United StatesEnvironment: Science and Policy for Sustainable Development, 2000
- Nuclear Power and the Public2000
- Cross-Cultural Risk Perception2000
- Risk vs. Risk1995
- Risk and Rationality1991
- Uncertainty and Quality in Science for Policy1990
- Legal Transplants: An Approach to Comparative LawStanford Law Review, 1975
- Experiments in Intergroup DiscriminationScientific American, 1970