The black cutworm, Agrotis ipsilon, is a critical underground pest of tobacco in the early season. Although numerous studies have provided chemical control against A. ipsilon through soil-surface or foliar application, relatively little is known about the efficacy of transplant application methods. Here, the control efficiency of insecticide transplant treatment against A. ipsilon in tobacco was evaluated in pots and fields, and we further investigated the impact of chlorantraniliprole on tobacco, including dynamic residue concentrations in tobacco and variation in agronomic traits of the treated seedlings. In the bioassay, chlorantraniliprole showed the highest toxicity (LC50 = 0.28 mg AI/L) against A. ipsilon among the tested insecticides. In the pot experiment, chlorantraniliprole treatment at 15, 30, and 75 g AI/ha significantly reduced the number of damaged tobacco seedlings and increased the mortality of A. ipsilon within 20 d. When tobacco seedlings were treated with chlorantraniliprole 1 d before transplanting in the field experiment, the control efficiency of chlorantraniliprole treatment at 75 g AI/ha was 45.5% at 20 d after treatment. The concentration of chlorantraniliprole in tobacco seedlings was found to degrade to 0.033 mg/kg after 28 d of treatment (t1/2 = 2.54), and this insecticide treatment affected the height of seedlings rather than the number of leaves at 28 d after treatment. It was confirmed that chlorantraniliprole treatment of seedlings during transplanting is a promising management strategy for the control of A. ipsilon in tobacco in the field, highlighting its practical, effective and economic advantages compared with broadcast spays on the soil surface and leaves.