Effect Size Rules of Thumb for One‐Dimensional Functional Data With an Application to Gait Analysis
- 8 June 2026
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Statistics in Medicine
- Vol. 45 (13-14) , e70633
Abstract
When analyzing gait and other human movements, often one‐dimensional (1D) functional data are considered, where a variable like joint angle changes smoothly over time from movement start to end. Interpretation of effect sizes in functional data like these generally follows the widely‐cited Cohen/Sawilowsky rules of thumb. A key problem is that a given effect size occurs with greater probability for functional data than for the simple scalar (0D) case of Cohen/Sawilowsky. Here, we propose both (i) functional effect size rules of thumb that are probabilistically consistent with the Cohen/Sawilowsky guidelines for a benchmark, two‐sample scenario, and (ii) a framework for adapting the benchmark interpretations to arbitrary experimental scenarios with probabilistic consistency. Analysis of an open total hip arthroplasty gait dataset showed that post‐surgery effect sizes would be interpreted as ‘medium’ and ‘less than very small’ for the Cohen/Sawilowsky and proposed functional rules of thumb, respectively. Adapting the benchmark case to the actual experimental case (paired design with = 52 and highly smooth functional residuals) contrastingly yielded an effect size interpretation of ‘very large’. These stark interpretation contrasts suggest that a single set of interpretation guidelines should not be applied to arbitrary experimental scenarios. We recommend using the Cohen/Sawilowsky and proposed functional rules of thumb only for a priori power analysis, and only in the absence of information regarding population variance and smoothness. For all other cases, especially post hoc effect size interpretation, we recommend using the proposed framework to yield probabilistically consistent results, and thus more meaningful cross‐study interpretations. Code replicating all results is available at https://github.com/0todd0000/esrot1d .Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- Kinematic and Kinetic Changes after Total Hip Arthroplasty during Sit-To-Stand Transfers: Systematic ReviewArthroplasty Today, 2021
- Confidence Sets for Cohen’s d effect size imagesNeuroImage, 2021
- Systematic review and meta-analysis of gait mechanics in young and older adultsExperimental Gerontology, 2017
- Coordinate based random effect size meta-analysis of neuroimaging studiesNeuroImage, 2017
- Effect Size Estimation in NeuroimagingJAMA Psychiatry, 2017
- The probability of false positives in zero-dimensional analyses of one-dimensional kinematic, force and EMG trajectoriesJournal of Biomechanics, 2016
- Set-level threshold-free tests on the intrinsic volumes of SPMsNeuroImage, 2013
- The effect of osteoarthritis definition on prevalence and incidence estimates: a systematic reviewOsteoarthritis and Cartilage, 2011
- Gait analysis as a quantifiable outcome measure in hip or knee osteoarthritis: A systematic reviewJoint Bone Spine, 2010
- Unified univariate and multivariate random field theoryNeuroImage, 2004