Inter- and intra-physician variability in insulin injection adjustments compared with Bayesian algorithm recommendations in type 1 diabetes
- 15 December 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Diabetologia
- Vol. 69 (4) , 872-882
Abstract
Aims/hypothesis There is an unmet need for automated insulin adjustments for multiple daily injections in type 1 diabetes under unsupervised use. We aimed to assess the McGill decision support system (DSS), which comprises a Bayesian algorithm, by comparing its automated insulin adjustments with those made by endocrinologists. Methods We surveyed 13 Canadian endocrinologists who made mock insulin adjustments in three separate parts on retrospective participants’ data. Part A (weekly data) and part C (biweekly data) compared the recommendations from physicians with those of the algorithm. Part B evaluated intra-physician variability by comparing the recommendations made by the same physician over time based on an identical dataset to part A. Results In part A, the agreement rate (mean [SD]) on the direction of weekly adjustments between the algorithm and physicians was non-inferior to the agreement rate between physicians for prandial bolus (55% [5] vs 56% [7], respectively; p=0.006) and basal insulin (48% [6] vs 51% [11], respectively; p=0.037). Low full disagreement rates on weekly adjustments were also comparable between the pairs for prandial bolus (3.9% [2.3] vs 4.1% [2.3], respectively; p=0.006) and basal insulin (10.6% [4.6] vs 9.2% [7.1], respectively; p=0.23). Similar rates were observed for biweekly insulin adjustments in part C. When comparing intra-physician decisions in part A with those in part B, on average, physicians fully agreed with themselves 66% (SD 7) and 67% (SD 7) of the time for prandial bolus and basal insulin adjustments, respectively. Conclusions/interpretation The direction of insulin adjustments was comparable between physicians and the McGill algorithm. The large intra-physician variability further emphasises the subjective nature of insulin management. Graphical AbstractKeywords
Funding Information
- Canada Research Chairs
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- A Bayesian decision support system for automated insulin doses in adults with type 1 diabetes on multiple daily injections: a randomized controlled trialNature Communications, 2025
- Comparison of Insulin Dose Adjustments Made by Artificial Intelligence-Based Decision Support Systems and by Physicians in People with Type 1 Diabetes Using Multiple Daily Injections TherapyDiabetes Technology & Therapeutics, 2022
- Adjustment of Insulin Pump Settings in Type 1 Diabetes Management: Advisor Pro Device Compared to Physicians’ RecommendationsJournal of Diabetes Science and Technology, 2020
- A Model-Based Insulin Dose Optimization Algorithm for People With Type 1 Diabetes on Multiple Daily Injections TherapyIEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering, 2020
- Cognitive and Human Factors in Expert Decision Making: Six Fallacies and the Eight Sources of BiasAnalytical Chemistry, 2020
- An artificial intelligence decision support system for the management of type 1 diabetesNature Metabolism, 2020
- State of Type 1 Diabetes Management and Outcomes from the T1D Exchange in 2016–2018Diabetes Technology & Therapeutics, 2019
- Adjusting insulin doses in patients with type 1 diabetes who use insulin pump and continuous glucose monitoring: Variations among countries and physiciansDiabetes, Obesity and Metabolism, 2018
- Recommendations for Standardizing Glucose Reporting and Analysis to Optimize Clinical Decision Making in Diabetes: The Ambulatory Glucose Profile (AGP)Diabetes Technology & Therapeutics, 2013
- The Effect of Intensive Treatment of Diabetes on the Development and Progression of Long-Term Complications in Insulin-Dependent Diabetes MellitusNew England Journal of Medicine, 1993