Legitimacy

Authors:

Abstract
This chapter examines legitimacy as the judgement employees make about whether their organization’s stated purpose aligns with their own values (propriety) and whether colleagues genuinely endorse it (validity). It argues that legitimacy is not a static attribute that leadership can project through communication but a dynamic assessment continuously shaped by observed behaviour at the team level. The chapter demonstrates that introducing a purpose yields a baseline performance increase of approximately 10%. However, team composition decisively moderates this effect: When an explicit prosocial purpose is matched with a high-prosociality team, performance gains reach 34%, whereas imposing the same purpose on a low-prosociality team degrades performance by 13% below the no-purpose baseline. The chapter illustrates these dynamics through cases, including BrewDog, whose prosocial workforce became its most damaging critics when leadership behaviour contradicted stated values, and Wells Fargo, where a corrupt de facto purpose overrode the official one. The identified blocker is mismatch between purpose content and team motivational composition. The chapter concludes with practical guidance on assessing team prosocial orientation and differentiating leadership strategies accordingly.

This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit: