Moving Explanations Closer to Humans: A Systematic Review of Comparisons of Explainable AI Implementations
Preprint
- 7 September 2026
- preprint
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Abstract
As AI increasingly supports human decision-making, designing clear and usable explanations has become a key challenge. Explainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI) aims to address this challenge, yet it remains unclear which explanation characteristics contribute to effective human-AI interaction. Following PRISMA guidelines, this systematic review synthesizes evidence from 161 empirical studies that directly compared multiple XAI implementations using human-centered evaluation metrics. Studies were analyzed across four explanation aspects: method, content, format, and interaction. Results were highly heterogeneous and often showed limited or non-significant differences between explanation implementations. Variations in explanation methods and content rarely produced consistent effects on user outcomes. In contrast, user-facing design choices, particularly explanation format and interaction, showed more consistent effects on user-related outcomes. Overall, the findings suggest that explanation effectiveness depends less on the underlying algorithm and more on how explanations are presented and experienced, highlighting the importance of a user-centered design perspective for XAI research and practice.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 210 references indexed in Scilit:
- Effects of explainable artificial intelligence in neurology decision supportAnnals of Clinical and Translational Neurology, 2024
- Trust in Machine Learning Driven Clinical Decision Support Tools Among OtolaryngologistsThe Laryngoscope, 2024
- Explainable artificial intelligence and social science: Further insights for qualitative investigationApplied AI Letters, 2022
- How level of explanation detail affects human performance in interpretable intelligent systems: A study on explainable fact checkingApplied AI Letters, 2021
- Interactive and Explainable Advising Dashboard Opens the Black Box of Student Success Prediction2021
- Trust Indicators and Explainable AI: A Study on User Perceptions2021
- Effects of Interactivity and Presentation on Review-Based Explanations for Recommendations2021
- Sage Advice? The Impacts of Explanations for Machine Learning Models on Human Decision-Making in Spam Detection2021
- Explainable Agents for Less Bias in Human-Agent Decision Making2020
- Towards Explainable Artificial Intelligence2019