Public healthcare resource allocation and the Rule of Rescue
- 30 June 2008
- journal article
- research article
- Published by BMJ in Journal of Medical Ethics
- Vol. 34 (7) , 540-544
Abstract
In healthcare, a tension sometimes arises between the injunction to do as much good as possible with scarce resources and the injunction to rescue identifiable individuals in immediate peril, regardless of cost (the “Rule of Rescue”). This tension can generate serious ethical and political difficulties for public policy makers faced with making explicit decisions about the public funding of controversial health technologies, such as costly new cancer drugs. In this paper we explore the appropriate role of the Rule of Rescue in public resource allocation decisions by health technology funding advisory bodies such as the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence. We consider practical approaches to operationalising the Rule of Rescue from Australia and the UK before examining the relevance of individual moral imperatives to public policy making. We conclude that that whilst public policy makers in a humane society should facilitate exceptional departures from a cost effectiveness norm in clinical decisions about identified individuals, it is not so obvious that they should, as a matter of national public policy, exempt any one group of unidentified individuals within society from the rules of opportunity cost at the expense of all others.Keywords
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- Wickedness or folly? The ethics of NICE’s decisionsJournal of Medical Ethics, 2006
- The Rule of RescueSocial Science & Medicine, 2003
- The ‘fair innings argument’ deserves a fairer hearing! comments by Alan Williams on Nord and JohannessonHealth Economics, 2001
- Principles of justice in health care rationingJournal of Medical Ethics, 2000
- Cost-Value Analysis in Health Care1999
- Explaining the Identifiable Victim EffectJournal of Risk and Uncertainty, 1997
- Equity and equality in health and health careJournal of Health Economics, 1993
- Setting Health Care Priorities in OregonJAMA, 1991
- Good, Fairness and QALYsRoyal Institute of Philosophy Lecture Series, 1988
- The Allocation of Exotic Medical Lifesaving TherapyEthics, 1969