Heavy reliance on a single biomass feedstock poses significant challenges for commercial biomanufacturing due to supply variability, cost uncertainty, and quality degradation during storage. Biomass blending offers a flexible strategy to mitigate these risks; however, its economic implications at scale remain insufficiently understood. This study evaluates a field-to-lignocellulosic sugar production system using single feedstocks and blends derived from 11 herbaceous and 11 woody biomass types. A total of 24 herbaceous and 31 woody blends were identified using a multi-factor decision matrix and random sampling approach. Results show that blending significantly improves the stability of the minimum sugar selling price (MSSP). Herbaceous blends exhibit the most favorable economic performance, achieving the lowest median MSSP (~$0.38/kg) and the narrowest cost distribution, while single woody feedstocks display the highest volatility and median costs. Although woody blends retain a broader price range, they eliminate extreme high-cost outliers observed in single-feedstock scenarios. Net-zero sugar production is achievable with a lignin-oil value of approximately $2.2/kg, and several blends achieve MSSP values below $0.40/kg. Downstream analysis using models for isoprenol, 1,4-dimethylcyclooctane (DMCO), and indigoidine indicates that cost stabilization through blending extends to final products. While biofuel pathways remain above current market prices, indigoidine demonstrates strong economic potential. Overall, blending enhances cost stability and reduces risk, with high-value bioproducts and lignin valorization representing key pathways to economic viability.